As long as it's okay only if you teach your child at earlier age to respect your rule before their puberty time comes. It's too late to teach teenagers to not do that...
Correct, which is why the lesson of responsibility must be taught earlier, and why I think Alan should bear some of the responsibility in this. Not all, but definitely some.
Alan is 9 years old, not teenager. Now he knows about 0190. If he do that again next time then he has to pay.
And this time he has no responsibility at all? Even if I didn't know about a specific thing that was wrong, at that age it was very easy to tell that a friend was doing something against the rules. The body language, the tone of voice, all gave it away.
It's parents who are responsible to teach the children to do that or not do that at earlier. It's parent's responsible if they forget to teach their children something. That's why I gave Alan a chance then he will learn to not do that next time because I know he didn't know that he is allow to touch 0190 but 0137. It's my fault. No matter either he learn from others or not but it's still my fault to not tell him to not touch 0190.
Parents also have a responsibility to teach their children that their actions come with consequences. I think a punishment should be a little lighter if the child didn't know and was honest about what happened--but there still has to be a punishment or else they come away thinking that they aren't responsible for anything they do.
No, it's parent's failure discipline to expose the kids into wrong way.
The parents did have a problem here--but children cannot be taught that they bear no responsibility for anything they do.
It has nothing do with "sheltering" children... but I beleive what I doing right to not accept responsible for that sex phone bill and also accept my responsible for not warn Alan about 0190 in first place. It's Ken's mother and my responsible. Alan & I talked about this yesterday. I let him share his feeling with me.
I beleive to share feeling with my children with questions and answers instead of jump and anger on them after listen someone but take BOTH sides to listen before I made action.
So none of the responsibility belongs to Alan at all? Don't you think that if he understood why the other number was wrong, he should've been smart enough to understand that the other one was wrong for the very same reasons, that when you call 0190, the same thing happens as with the other number? I would not underestimate a child's intelligence in that way.
Well, I would say it's your responsible, not 16 years old teenager. Why? Because you let teenager drive alone.
16 years old is smart enough to understand the responsibility that comes with a car. I would have made it very clear to the teenager before driving alone that it IS a major responsibility. In the state where I received my license, all teenagers must
go to court with their parents in order to receive their license. A state judge awards the license to a group of teens. Even if this doesn't happen in the state where I'll be living when I have a child that age, I will make the responsibility VERY clear: that owning and using a car is like learning to own and use a gun responsibly--both things have the power to take lives if used improperly.
What if they have big car accident? Who pay? Of course YOU.
Maybe right away, but you'd better believe I'd get that money back somehow IF the accident were ruled by the police to be their fault (if it was not ruled to be their fault then that's a different story). If it were an accident with a lot of damage, that kid would be getting a job or doing work for me (mowing the lawn, etc.) so that I could it back.
Traffic ticket is a different story because you teach your 16 years old to not park illegal parking in first place... It's his/her responsible to ignore your warning and have to pay himself/herself.
Right, but by that age a 16 year old should be responsible enough to be able to read a sign that says it's illegal to park in that spot, even if I don't expressly say so. Why should I have to tell my child
everything? How does he or she learn to analyze a new situation and make a proper decision if I spoon-feed everything to him?
Well, I have to travel today, so I think this thread is going to move on without me...later!