I think that is the way to go, follow your religion truly and you will reap the fruits. Well, my religion, Hinduism is a mythical one, its so beautiful and I tresure every respect of my being a hindu!!
Glad to know you are a staunch catholic, I went to a Catholic school in Middle High School, the school was called Maris Stella, I learnt a lot about the catholic faith including the various masses, like Ash Wednesday, Easter Sunday, etc... I learnt about communion, etc. Also I liked the hymns...I still remember Hail Mary, full of grace!
Just be comfortable with yourself, and you would be fine...thats my point.
Kashveera