Mom Makes Daughter Stand on Street Corner

[Liebling:-)))]

If the child needs help with their schooling, Ask for help.

Exactly - the child needs support, not get punish from her/his parents.

This article shows that the mother does care about her daughter's grade has nothing to do with the daughter being neglect.

No, I never say that a mother neglect her daughter. I only disagree what her mother did to her daughter because of damage her emotional. A mother thought it works but it will doesn´t.

There are some teens and children out there who doesn't want to work hard or care to improve their grades and schooling.

Yes

Now, the mother wouldn't make the daughter stand on the corner if she didn't care about her daughter's bright future.

Yes, I can see that she care about her daughter but she did what she thought is works but it doesn´t. I know she tried to help her daughter but it´s too extreme what she did to her.

I've seen a true story movie about a mother being on crack, and this bright teen worked her way up to finish high school and enrolled herself in college.

Yes, you are right. I have seen some of people who did that. Example about me, I look at my parent´s role and then look at some of my friend´s parent´s role and prefer my friend´s parent´s role. Of course I saw Family Barnes on the TV and want to be like them... Some of people do like that. Yes.

 

[Liebling:-)))]

Originally Posted by diehardbiker65
there is NO one discipline that fits all. Some form of discipline works for some kids while other don't.

Yes, true but what a mother did to her daughter is not belong to form of discipline but harsh punishment.

Originally Posted by diehardbiker65
I think we, the public have NO business telling parents what to do with their kids! I think public telling parents what to do with their kids do far more damaging than leaving them alone let them work on their course.

Well, why a mother let newspaper to spread out to public then? It look like she is sort of "bragging" to show up how her "discipline" works on her daughter. She wants everyone judge her daughter... but me,, not... I JUDGE a mother, not daughter. Why? She ASK for it.

A mother makes her daughter stand on street corner and then plus allow the reporters to press the newspapers to name them to everyone...

I would not spread my child out to the newspapers for everyone to judge her daughter after punish her harsh to the public... ***goose pumps***

I would not tell parents to do with their children because what they did is PRIVATELY... We share our discipline on our kids what good or bad...and respect each other, not judge each other...

I can image how a daughter feel after read the newspaper on next day... *googe pump* I feel want to hug her.

 

[Liebling:-)))]

It's just questions - no harm done. You are still entitled to your opinions.

Okay

I still don't agree about some of things you've stated here about psychological/emotional issues. I don't believe in "self-esteem" either... that's my opinion.

I see no problem to have you to disagree with me. To me, healthy self-esteem is most important.

Okay, you said that you dont beleive in self-esteem... Everyone including you and me have form of esteems. What is kind of esteem, you beleive in?

 

[Reba]

No, it´s not just sexual pleasure, but burnt their bodies with smoking.... out of fun... let them starving to death...

I meant the Hustler editorial viewpoint. Their magazine does NOT care about abused children. The only reason they printed that article was because they knew it would appeal to the pruient (nasty) interests of their readers. The kind of people who read Hustler want to see nasty pictures and read graphic descriptions of sex and torture. They are not concerned parents! People who look at Hustler want to get turned on, not informed. In your link story, the pull quotes and captions made sexual insinuations not related to the real topic of child abuse.

Really, you should read your links more critically (with deep analysis) before posting them. Also, check for legitimate resources. Porn rags are not good resources for serious information.

 

[Reba]

Boys? Are you talking about 18 years old.

They have CHOICE is go to Army for 10 months training OR work at mental hospital after finish their school education.

American HAVE to register when they reach 18 years old. They have NO choice.

I remember the thread somwhere here... I will link to show you....

American males age 18 must register but they are NOT required to join the military. There is no military draft in America now.

Wow, working at a mental hospital--that will be useful if Germany is attacked by another country!

 

[Reba]

And? That´s just his name. All what I gave the link is children abuse, not porn.

Your link was an article from a porn magazine.

 

[Reba]

I already mentioned in my previous post - pension money. (it call "early retirement benefit".

You said that applied to people who used to work but couldn't work after one year. I am asking about people who never, never work, not even one day. That is not "retirement". Someone has to work before they can retire. You can't retire from a job that you never had.

Yes, it´s exactly same as in Germany - we work to pay tax to government.

Not, it is not the same. I do NOT work just to pay tax to the government. I said, "No, I work to support me and my family, and because I enjoy my work. I pay state and federal income taxes because it is required. I also pay sales tax, property tax, personal property tax, gas tax, etc."

Sales and property taxes are not related to work.

 

[Reba]

it´s no force... they give germans time to finish their education, trainings, etc. first then...... then make choice what they wants...

Americans has no choice and have to register when they search 18 years old which different as Germany or any countries....

Americans register but they can continue their education, no problem. Registering does not prevent them from attending college, getting jobs, whatever.

 

[Maria]

You pointed your finger on me for made my off topic post? only me?

Why can´t you say something to some of members who made their topic off, too?



Correct

It's not a finger pointin'. Once the members read this, it includes them as well since they are members of this AD. I am not mad at you. Ok ? Just a friendly request. That's all.

 

[Reba]

:Oops:

 

[diehardbiker]

I think you best take few steps backwards and look at the whole picture. I have seen as young as 8 years old that is BRAT, TYRANY, and OUT OF CONTROL. Once the child gets out of control, sometimes firm or extreme discipline is needed. Believe it or not we have murderer who is only 7 years old and it happened just an hour south of where I live! I can't forget the name of that flame red head boy, it is Eric Smith Back then was 7 years old killed 5 years old Derrick. That happened about 11 years ago. Thats real extreme, and the world blamed on parents for doing nothing about it! Is that a fact? I don't think so, something must have gone haywired down the road.
Who am I blame to, for this tragedy? My answer is EVERYBODY!

What this mother did was NOT harsh punishment. It was not even in abuse category at all! I am sorry, but I stand behind this mother all the way! She had done great deal to make difference in her daughter's life for better. Just watch, I can bet you that this girl will have blessing life later on! That is her reward for having best mother who is firm believer in discipline.

Spreading word can have positive impact on other kids. This will enable other parents think and suggest their kids if they don't act up, they will do this (Showing newspaper to their kids). I am sure that this will work on some brats. And these newspaper can have lasting reminder of this daughter the true world of consequences.

Yes, true but what a mother did to her daughter is not belong to form of discipline but harsh punishment.



Well, why a mother let newspaper to spread out to public then? It look like she is sort of "bragging" to show up how her "discipline" works on her daughter. She wants everyone judge her daughter... but me,, not... I JUDGE a mother, not daughter. Why? She ASK for it.

A mother makes her daughter stand on street corner and then plus allow the reporters to press the newspapers to name them to everyone...

I would not spread my child out to the newspapers for everyone to judge her daughter after punish her harsh to the public... ***goose pumps***

I would not tell parents to do with their children because what they did is PRIVATELY... We share our discipline on our kids what good or bad...and respect each other, not judge each other...

I can image how a daughter feel after read the newspaper on next day... *googe pump* I feel want to hug her.

 

[MsGiglz]

I am really glad that you and counselors work together to help your daughter. What about sport? Have your daughter any hobbies? which it's good for her to do something with her hobbies.
[COLOR]

She used to be play basketball team, she quitted. I tried to encourage her to go back to basketball. She dont want to. She just dont want to do anything and be lazy. Her hobbies are listening music.. I have been watching which music she listen to... some music can lead to commit scuide or bad life. I went kids to Sunday School and Wednesday classes at our church. She likes sewing. she sew some and design some clothes but just recently stopped.. All she wants to go out at Mall but our Mall doesnt allow teenagers go without parents. I cant go Mall all the times, I have other things to do with other kids.. I signed her up as much I can to get her involved, she kept not going or ditch it.

Wow $10 to $15 every week is too much... What you treat your children about allowance is right. Amy should be glad to have $10 to $15 because they are volunalilty... My children got EUR 12 and EUR 9 each month to follow their ages and know that it's only volunatliry. I can see that Amy is a diffuiclt child and hate about herself. Is Amy eldest child of 6 children? I pray that everything will goes smooth for you and Amy. Stick your limit firm then she will know you didn't give up.

Its not too much, we are living in high cost living.. our economy in Minnesota are horrible. But Mack and Mallory managed so well to find something else than spend silly thing. They found cheap to rent movies for 1.99, home made popcorn and their own pop. Or they find what we need for baking supplies, so they can bake cookies or cakes.. Amy just bought whole her money on candies or junk food. I encouraged her to save to buy her favorite Cds.. She doesnt care.. always expected us to buy for her. Most kids around here gets 20-30 or 50 per week. That's why Amy is upset..

Show Amy that you are a strong and boss is the best. I can understand about your healthy issue... I feel want to you.

She does know about my healthy issue and she dont give a damn about it. From now on... My man and I just discuss that I couldnt manage because so much stress, I went back smoking as I tried to stop. He said from now on if the kids giving me hard time. Leave it up to him. So far it works but he needs to be more strict. LOL... well.. I only asking for New year resoultion... give me more strength to stop smoking, and reconile my lovely Amy...

 

[MsGiglz]

I think you best take few steps backwards and look at the whole picture. I have seen as young as 8 years old that is BRAT, TYRANY, and OUT OF CONTROL. Once the child gets out of control, sometimes firm or extreme discipline is needed. Believe it or not we have murderer who is only 7 years old and it happened just an hour south of where I live! I can't forget the name of that flame red head boy, it is Eric Smith Back then was 7 years old killed 5 years old Derrick. That happened about 11 years ago. Thats real extreme, and the world blamed on parents for doing nothing about it! Is that a fact? I don't think so, something must have gone haywired down the road.
Who am I blame to, for this tragedy? My answer is EVERYBODY!

What this mother did was NOT harsh punishment. It was not even in abuse category at all! I am sorry, but I stand behind this mother all the way! She had done great deal to make difference in her daughter's life for better. Just watch, I can bet you that this girl will have blessing life later on! That is her reward for having best mother who is firm believer in discipline.

Spreading word can have positive impact on other kids. This will enable other parents think and suggest their kids if they don't act up, they will do this (Showing newspaper to their kids). I am sure that this will work on some brats. And these newspaper can have lasting reminder of this daughter the true world of consequences.

Thank you to clarify that.. You made crystal point view. It is NOT HARSH punishment.

Yes. Spreading word.. Kids will learn lessons or wake up call.

 

[Liebling:-)))]

American males age 18 must register but they are NOT required to join the military. There is no military draft in America now.

Wow, working at a mental hospital--that will be useful if Germany is attacked by another country!

I already answered my previous post to correct my mistake because I thought it´s only mental hospital which it´s not. It´s up to Germans to choose which civil servant/duty they want to pick to work for 9 months.

Liebling´s post.
I just found out by my eldest son and hubby today during our meal converstion that it´s not only Mental hospital they join to for 9 months but "Civil Servants/Duty" - something like that clean at streets, graves, old people homes, mental homes, hospitails, work at farm etc. etc. etc.

My children were taught at school about this. We met our former child minder at store today. She told me that her 20 years old son work at clinic since last September instead of join to Army for 9 months and love it. He finished his Education last September then decide for Civil Servant/Duty... Clinic as carer... I ask my eldest son either he want to join Army or civil servant/duty.. My eldest son said that he want to join Army to learn how to defend himself but my young son said he want to join Civil Servant/Duty.

 

[Liebling:-)))]

You said that applied to people who used to work but couldn't work after one year. I am asking about people who never, never work, not even one day. That is not "retirement". Someone has to work before they can retire. You can't retire from a job that you never had.

As what you mean severe disabled people who are unable to work rest of their life. I saw a lot of disabled people work for "warehouse" to do with woods, wrap the papers, etc. etc. They get special apartment for disabled - Government pays their rents, utility used & foods. They sells crafts every twice a year - summer and christmas... their crafts are very beautiful... they sells to support their life. We went there to buy anything from them every summer at BBQ party.

Not, it is not the same. I do NOT work just to pay tax to the government. I said, "No, I work to support me and my family, and because I enjoy my work. I pay state and federal income taxes because it is required. I also pay sales tax, property tax, personal property tax, gas tax, etc."

Yes, I work to support my family life. Of course tax obligation go to government from month income to support country like buildings, etc. etc. etc...,
Of course gas tax, oil tax, property tax, utilities tax etc. etc.

Sales and property taxes are not related to work.

Right.

 

[Liebling:-)))]

It's not a finger pointin'. Once the members read this, it includes them as well since they are members of this AD. I am not mad at you. Ok ? Just a friendly request. That's all.

Not finger pointing? Yes, you have. If you don´t want to have off topic on your thread then you should say "Dear members, let´s go back to that topic of this thread........"

CyberRed´s post
Leiblin' : Let's go back to that topic of this thread that I just provided in page one ... shall we ? And, please stick with it about "Mom makes daughter stand on street corner" -- not the governement and kids stuff. Thanks.

 

[Liebling:-)))]

I will be back for response some of your posts .

 

[Reba]

As what you mean severe disabled people who are unable to work rest of their life. I saw a lot of disabled people work for "warehouse" to do with woods, wrap the papers, etc. etc.

I mean really disabled people who can do NO work. Have you ever met a really disabled person? Our Pastor's daughter was a twin born with CP. (Her sister died at birth.) She is hard-of-hearing and legally blind. She has never walked. She has severe seizures. She has a very low IQ. She can only speak a few words (she is in her 30's). She can't use her hands much because they can't grip well. She can't feed, bathe or dress herself, or use a toilet. She has never been to school, never had a job. At the residential center where she lives, she is one of the better off. Most of the other residents are even more handicapped. THAT is what I mean. How does the German government take care of severly, permanently handicapped people?

 

[Liebling:-)))]

I mean really disabled people who can do NO work. Have you ever met a really disabled person? Our Pastor's daughter was a twin born with CP. (Her sister died at birth.) She is hard-of-hearing and legally blind. She has never walked. She has severe seizures. She has a very low IQ. She can only speak a few words (she is in her 30's). She can't use her hands much because they can't grip well. She can't feed, bathe or dress herself, or use a toilet. She has never been to school, never had a job. At the residential center where she lives, she is one of the better off. Most of the other residents are even more handicapped. THAT is what I mean. How does the German government take care of severly, permanently handicapped people?

Yes, they receive special benefit from medical rehabiliation benefit & also more children benefit. If the parents who want to keep their severe disabled children then they will receive special benefit to take care of their severe disabled children and also get very low tax pay, too. (one of married partners go to work - pay very low tax.) - if there're single mother of severe disabled children, then get more special benefit than married couples. If the parents can't cope to take care of their disabled children then put them to nursing home - special benefit money and children support benefit go to nursing home to take care of their disabled children. Depend how much married couple's income - they have to pay % to add special benefit and children support benefit (they count how much they pay tax because they pay very low tax to meet nursing home's cost).

We (every parents) recieved monthly children support benefit from government where the taxpayers go to, to develop our children's future but with severe disabled children, they get more than us.

I will be glad to explain you again if you don't understand what I mean.


*forgive me for not reply some of your posts an earlier...* I am going home now and will be back for respond some of your posts...

 

[Liebling:-)))]

I think you best take few steps backwards and look at the whole picture.

Why? because it´s true.

I have seen as young as 8 years old that is BRAT, TYRANY, and OUT OF CONTROL. Once the child gets out of control, sometimes firm or extreme discipline is needed.

Where children´s behavior come from?

Why Children Misbehave
http://www.k-state.edu/wwparent/courses/rd/rd4.htm

Believe it or not we have murderer who is only 7 years old and it happened just an hour south of where I live! I can't forget the name of that flame red head boy, it is Eric Smith Back then was 7 years old killed 5 years old Derrick. That happened about 11 years ago. Thats real extreme, and the world blamed on parents for doing nothing about it! Is that a fact? I don't think so, something must have gone haywired down the road.

7 years old killed his own brother Derrick?... It sounds that he´s jealous of his brother? It look like that he has very low esteem and feel being worthless and began jealous of his brother who get a lot of attention from their parents?

Who am I blame to, for this tragedy? My answer is EVERYBODY!

Disagree! Why? it´s not logical to blame everyone to expose 7 years old into murder. Teenagers are different story due puberty but young children? It´s something do with his parent´s background how to expose 7 years old like this.

What this mother did was NOT harsh punishment. It was not even in abuse category at all! I am sorry, but I stand behind this mother all the way! She had done great deal to make difference in her daughter's life for better. Just watch, I can bet you that this girl will have blessing life later on! That is her reward for having best mother who is firm believer in discipline.

Disagree: Did you know what public humiliation is? Of course it´s not discipline but harsh punishment. To me, public humiliation is a pathetic and bullying on child´s self-esteem. It´s an emotional abuse. No she will never learn her lesson but her behavior will back again anytime... then worst and worst...

I´m agree with comments in some links what they think about this situation.

http://msgboard.snopes.com/cgi-bin/ultimatebb.cgi?ubb=get_topic;f=53;t=002678;p=3
http://fornits.com/wwf/viewtopic.php?forum=9&topic=12677

Spreading word can have positive impact on other kids. This will enable other parents think and suggest their kids if they don't act up, they will do this (Showing newspaper to their kids). I am sure that this will work on some brats. And these newspaper can have lasting reminder of this daughter the true world of consequences.

Don´t even blame the young children.
Don´t even label the young children as brat.
How/Where/Why they learn from? Of course it´s parent´s form of discipline who expose them into kind of behavior.

I know teenagers are different story due puberty time.