Do animal have soul?

Reba said:
Not allowed to discuss heaven here.
Click to expand...

It's not need to call true or false.

I have respect to people who believe or not.
 
Defee said:
Oh boy, im finding myself repeating like an old broken
record.......aaargh!
You gotta feel guilty then if you kill an animal since you
believe they have souls just like you would if you kill
an human being, right?
Also dont you feel bad, since they have souls, you do
eat them?...:eek3:
Click to expand...

Ok, I'm going to answer.

Damn, I need make excuse for like that but I do choose pets to have soul as human but for animal like cow, pig, fish and chicken aren't my strong concern, also used to be so but not anymore.

I don't want kill my couple of cute cats, they are same soul as human does.
 
Pacman said:
It's not need to call true or false.

I have respect to people who believe or not.
Click to expand...
I mean Alex doesn't want us to discuss heaven because that's a religion topic.
 
In my own opinion, yes Animals do have soul.
 
PuyoPiyo said:
Well this link says that animals do go to heaven. That's all I learned..
Click to expand...

We dont know that, PuyoPiyo if there is a h_____ for animals or
not, there is no positive proof of that, ok.
That link may say so, that is just an assumption of somebody's
part. It is not a concrete proof, thats all.

I think animals possess a different kind of soul, not the same
kind we, humans possess..
 
Pacman said:
Ok, I'm going to answer.

Damn, I need make excuse for like that but I do choose pets to have soul as human but for animal like cow, pig, fish and chicken aren't my strong concern, also used to be so but not anymore.

I don't want kill my couple of cute cats, they are same soul as human does.
Click to expand...

Oh, geez...of course not, you dont want to kill your cats! I love my
dog and i sure dont want to kill him, for what? My dog is my protective
friend as he knows im deaf.
What i meant is the animals we eat, pigs, cows, chickens, etc..they are
our food source, right? if people think they have "souls", well, do they
feel guilty eating their food sources (pigs,cows,chickens,etc)? thats my
point.
 
Defee said:
We dont know that, PuyoPiyo if there is a h_____ for animals or
not, there is no positive proof of that, ok.
That link may say so, that is just an assumption of somebody's
part. It is not a concrete proof, thats all.

I think animals possess a different kind of soul, not the same
kind we, humans possess..
Click to expand...

Everyone have varies of POV that's all ;)
 
Defee said:
Fine, why dont you prove that animals, repitiles, insects (!)
have "souls", please? so far, nobody has come up with definite
proof.
Click to expand...

Oh I have proof. You just won't believe it.

My rat Mango Lassi died in a fight. I got another rat called Nancy. She behaved very much like Mango. She even responded when I called her 'Mango'. Also my other rat Darktan seemed to recognise her. She's never seen Nancy before but knew Mango very well. So how do you explain that?

Yes, then there is also Mitzy. The night before Mitzy died I had a 'dream' about being a lab rat and having the infamous LD50 test done on me. It was like I was going through what Mitzy went through. As far as I've been told Mitzy wasn't from a laboritory. She was dumped in an allyway and the RSPCA took her in. So where were all these memories I was getting from her comming from if not from a previous incarnation?
 
Defee said:
Oh, geez...of course not, you dont want to kill your cats! I love my
dog and i sure dont want to kill him, for what? My dog is my protective
friend as he knows im deaf.
What i meant is the animals we eat, pigs, cows, chickens, etc..they are
our food source, right? if people think they have "souls", well, do they
feel guilty eating their food sources (pigs,cows,chickens,etc)? thats my
point.
Click to expand...

Yes, farm animals all have souls too. I used to know a couple of pigs at a city farm. I visited them but they were very depressed I think because they didn't have much to do. Not enough space. Then they were gone. I suppose they went the way all pigs do eventually. I thought it was really sad. I knew they had souls. I could just feel it. They certainly recognised me when I came.
 
**Sigh**
Here i go again....
Like i said before, maybe im just speculating, that
all animals may have different souls, not same as
humans' souls which is eternal. I dont know where
the animals souls go after they die, really. It dont
say in the B_____. I think they just turn to ashes
or something like that.
 
Well, when you and your pet die, you will not see your pet, but you will see your ancestors/families/friends. Animals and people are different after death. :)

And, of course animals do not reincarnation. They only live once...and die once. Not twice.
 
Maria said:
And, of course animals do not reincarnation. They only live once...and die once. Not twice.
Click to expand...

So how do you explain about Mitzy and Mango/Nancy? We all reincarnate. Animals included. That's how I know that animals have souls. Saying animals don't have souls is like saying people don't. It makes no sense to me. Plus heaven would be overcrowded if we all went there and stayed there. We only stay until we get reincarnated into another life.

Plus, how do you know that you won't see your animal friends in heaven? You've never died so you don't know.
 
dreama said:
So how do you explain about Mitzy and Mango/Nancy? We all reincarnate. Animals included. That's how I know that animals have souls. Saying animals don't have souls is like saying people don't. It makes no sense to me. Plus heaven would be overcrowded if we all went there and stayed there. We only stay until we get reincarnated into another life.

Plus, how do you know that you won't see your animal friends in heaven? You've never died so you don't know.
Click to expand...

Heaven would be overcrowded ? :lol: I don't think so, hon.... because, the universe is sooo B I G than our earth. Our earth is the size of one drop of water. :)

FYI, animal do not have an eternal spirit... different from a soul.
If, you believe that there's a reincarnation out there... then, that's YOUR belief. But, as for me, I don't believe that there's a reincarnation out there. That's like someone is recantin' or prayin' for loved ones to come out of the graves. :ugh3:

When I die, I know exact where I will go. ;)
 
Maria said:
...If, you believe that there's a reincarnation out there... then, that's YOUR belief. But, as for me, I don't believe that there's a reincarnation out there....
Click to expand...
I don't even understand how the math of reincarnation could work. The human and animal population increases with each generation, so if the same souls are reincarnating into different bodies each time, it seems there wouldn't be enough souls to occupy all the bodies. :confused:
 
God is probably recycling humans and animals on Earth. We turn into ash, and our souls flies into women's womb as a new life. :angel:
 
Back
Top