Do animal have soul?

Maria said:
Ohh, yes I DO understand the difference in between soul and spirit. FYI, I am NOT allowed to give out the details how I knew about the difference in between soul and spirit.

I take the 5th Amendment. :)
Click to expand...
Yes, how can we explain about spiritual topics without touching the forbidden "religion"? It's almost impossible.

I would like to give my viewpoint on the topic but it's not allowed. :(
 
I know it is frustrated. Now, since we couldnt say anything further, who goes the unbelievers, see christians doesn't know. LOL The truth we do know the answer, but yes, it is forbidden to discuss in christian's pov.
 
Maria said:
Ohh, yes I DO understand the difference in between soul and spirit. FYI, I am NOT allowed to give out the details how I knew about the difference in between soul and spirit.

I take the 5th Amendment. :)
Click to expand...
Me too, we just see things different.
 
Reba said:
Yes, how can we explain about spiritual topics without touching the forbidden "religion"? It's almost impossible.

And, I thought this AD's purpose is what : to educate, learn, share experiences, and give advices/suggestiions. But, then I guess it wasn't means to be. There will never be learnin' just for one missin'. :(

I would like to give my viewpoint on the topic but it's not allowed. :(
Click to expand...

I would like to, too. I guess, ___ is right. Someone proved ___ right.
 
Animals and people don't have the same non-physical component that is necessary for two-way communion with the source of their existence.
 
i believe that animals do have souls.. as i have seen my old dogs n my old cat patches in my dreams.. i know they came to see me and let me know they missed me and love me.. snuggled with me even for short time.. then after a while they would go back to where they belong.. Heaven... they are like us... we all have feelings... :) so yes they do have souls!
 
I never thought that some people brought the reglious issues here because it relate to Soul. That's not what I am talking about but feeling...(soul, not Soul) that's what the animals have.

Yes, Animals do have emotions.
Yes, Animals have personalities, likes & dislikes.
Yes, Animals like to play, bother you to play with them and get you attention...
Yes, Animals do have angry, protective, happy, etc.
Yes, Animals feel things like us.
Yes, Animals know how to respect us (only if we educate them well).
Yes, Animals could be aggressive, temper, loving, etc. like us.
 
Liebling:-))) said:
I never thought that some people brought the reglious issues here because it relate to Soul. That's not what I am talking about but feeling...(soul, not Soul) that's what the animals have.

Yes, Animals do have emotions.
Yes, Animals have personalities, likes & dislikes.
Yes, Animals like to play, bother you to play with them and get you attention...
Yes, Animals do have angry, protective, happy, etc.
Yes, Animals feel things like us.
Yes, Animals know how to respect us (only if we educate them well).
Yes, Animals could be aggressive, temper, loving, etc. like us.
Click to expand...

You are talkin' about " soul ". But, the animal do not possess an eternal spirit. That's different. The animal will simply and totally returns to the dust.
 
Maria said:
You are talkin' about " soul ". But, the animal do not possess an eternal spirit. That's different. The animal will simply and totally returns to the dust.
Click to expand...


Yes, I am talking about soul, not Soul.

There're many different soul interpretation. That's what I am talking about is

2. feelings: a person's emotional and moral nature, where the most private thoughts and feelings are hidden
soul
soul definition - Dictionary - MSN Encarta

Soul
Soul definition - Dictionary - MSN Encarta
Click to expand...
 
I don't know if animals have soul so I cannot answer this question at this time.
 
Liebling:-))) said:
I never thought that some people brought the reglious issues here because it relate to Soul. That's not what I am talking about but feeling...(soul, not Soul) that's what the animals have.

Yes, Animals do have emotions.
Yes, Animals have personalities, likes & dislikes.
Yes, Animals like to play, bother you to play with them and get you attention...
Yes, Animals do have angry, protective, happy, etc.
Yes, Animals feel things like us.
Yes, Animals know how to respect us (only if we educate them well).
Yes, Animals could be aggressive, temper, loving, etc. like us.
Click to expand...

Of course, we know that animals do have FEELINGS just like
humans. But there is difference between feelings and souls. I dont
know where you get the idea of little and capital letter of "s" of the word
"soul" it doesnt make any difference cuz it means the same thing whether
it is Soul or soul.
In your dictionaries you provided here..they mean the same thing..and it
does not say anything about animals soul...they just described what the
word "soul" means...it only said people's souls, thats it.
Like Maria said and i agree with her...animals do not possess eternal
spirt like humans do. They do not go to heaven when they die. I dont
know where they go when they die, really. It dont say anything about
that in the Bible.
If some people believe animals go to heaven, i dont know where they
get the idea, but im afraid its just a wishful perception on their part.
Its my opinion so dont bash on me, heh.
 
Defee said:
Of course, we know that animals do have FEELINGS just like
humans. But there is difference between feelings and souls. I dont
know where you get the idea of little and capital letter of "s" of the word
"soul" it doesnt make any difference cuz it means the same thing whether
it is Soul or soul.
Click to expand...

Yes that's what I questioned the difference between "s" and "S" in my previous post and want anyone to correct my post...

http://www.alldeaf.com/786790-post33.html

Nobody answer my question so I find out thru dictornary what is the difference between "s" and "S". I can see that "s" have many different interpretation than "S".

In your dictionaries you provided here..they mean the same thing..and it
does not say anything about animals soul...they just described what the
word "soul" means...it only said people's souls, thats it.
Click to expand...

The "soul" interpret in different way... like you see the list of meaning word of soul... I pick number 2 because person and animal have feeling and emotion.

Like Maria said and i agree with her...animals do not possess eternal
spirt like humans do. They do not go to heaven when they die. I dont
know where they go when they die, really. It dont say anything about
that in the Bible.
If some people believe animals go to heaven, i dont know where they
get the idea, but im afraid its just a wishful perception on their part.
Its my opinion so dont bash on me, heh.
Click to expand...

I really never thought about animals go to heaven until I created the thread here for a first time. I thought something different than animal's soul go to heaven.

Oh no, I do not bash on you or anyone... You has the right to have your own POV but we should be careful to not bring religous issues up here yet until Alex permit us then....
Click to expand...
 
PuyoPiyo said:
MOD! If this post is breaking the rule, please delete this post, thank you.

For the people who thought the bible didn't said anything about the animals, but it actually DO. Check this link out.

What does the bible say about animals/pets in Heaven
Click to expand...

wow, interesting link... I really never thought that animal's soul go up to heaven as I create a thread here. :eek3: I only know that animal has a soul because they have feeling, breath, pain, etc. like humans.

but we should be careful to not bring those issues up yet until Alex permit us then...
 
Liebling:-))) said:
Yes, I am talking about soul, not Soul.

There're many different soul interpretation. That's what I am talking about is

2. feelings: a person's emotional and moral nature, where the most private thoughts and feelings are hidden
soul
soul definition - Dictionary - MSN Encarta

Soul
Soul definition - Dictionary - MSN Encarta
Click to expand...


Those 2 links you provided do NOT mention about animal. It mentioned about a " person ". Lieblin', I do not think you get my point. The point is that the animal do NOT possess an eternal spirit. Animal possess a soul in the sense of " breathe " just like a human bein', but animal do NOT possess an eternal spirit. Understand ? That's why both of the animal and people are not the same.

I know it is hard for some people to understand this picture. I truly wish that Alex would allow me to explain some details or give some pictures, but I am NOT allowed to do so... so, therefore there will never be an education for all of us to learn by how, or what or why or when about this issue. We all don't have that benefits to understand. My lips are sealed. I am so sorry.
Click to expand...
 
PuyoPiyo said:
MOD! If this post is breaking the rule, please delete this post, thank you.

For the people who thought the bible didn't said anything about the animals, but it actually DO. Check this link out.

What does the bible say about animals/pets in Heaven
Click to expand...

It is full of assumptions, really, meaning these
people are assuming without proof, ok?
Animals do have feelings but they do not possess
eternal souls like human..maybe different kind of
souls?..i dont know.
 
Defee said:
It is full of assumptions, really, meaning these
people are assuming without proof, ok?
Animals do have feelings but they do not possess
eternal souls like human..maybe different kind of
souls?..i dont know.
Click to expand...

Well this link says that animals do go to heaven. That's all I learned..
 
Animals are probably to have different spirit from human, believe or not.
 
Back
Top