- Joined
- Oct 31, 2007
- Messages
- 2,424
- Reaction score
- 88
LOL! That's an apt description of our missionaries who come here to enlighten us to the error of our ways. They're like those Christian missionaries who come to the reservations of American Indians (many of them Christian) to save them from the Devil. There's an an old Indian (Indian Indian - not American Indian) saying that goes "If you think you're enlightened, you're not enlightened."
As for bees in your bonnet, you're quite welcome to them. :P I hated having them buzz over the microphone on my HA. Dunno how I'd feel about them buzing over my CI.
Thank you, thank you, thank you for underscoring my obscure rant with the perfect examples of "many members will agree with any view opposing anything."
Every guru and group (including old Indians in India) believe their enlightenment is the one and only true enlightenment. Although I didn't mention religious missionaries, their history certainly gives the term "mission" a distinct stereotype.
When trying to catagorize all of the many different civilizations of pre-Columbian peoples as one and point to their downfall, the Christian missionary is the perfect villian.
Let's skip over the on-going missions of these native civilizations for centuries before and after 1492 to enslave or wipe each other out.
Or the missions of merchant hordes in "the New World" to encourage the previous native mission with barter of liquor, guns, steel knives, etc., for animal pelts and precious metals.
Don't forget the missions of the gold seekers and land grabbers, followed by the military missions to protect miners and settlers. The mission of Manifest Destiny itself was secular in nature and not limited to the United States, as neighbors north and south practiced it.
An actual examination of tribal documents shows many, many tribes sent emissaries (there's that root term again) to ask (beg) for missionaries. The hope, which worked out for far too few tribes, was to seek protection of the missionaries.
But it seems the natives stereotyped as much as everyone else. They supposed all Europians were of one religion, not a plathura of sects (most Christian to be sure) but each different and each thinking its enlightenment was the true enlightenment.
Another all around failure was not to understand the new doctrine of separation of church and state. The different religions could scarcely protect themselves, much less the natives, though many missionaries died trying.
The epilogue that honey and pollination may be okay, but buzzing bees are hateful fits right in. (A bit more historical trivia is the kindest native term for bees, never seen in the Americas until European colonization was "white men's flies," kind of a metaphoric warning. The Gros Ventre were more direct: "crazy-fly-with-sweet-lure.")