What do you think are advantages of having a guide dog and what do you think are advantages of the long cane?
advantages of a guide dog:
1. being able to find a chair, counter or person easily.
2. i walk much faster with a guide dog than a cane, so speed is an advantage.
3. being able to navigate around construction sites with ease without having to run into barricades and search for holes in the ground with my cane.
4. being able to find the path of least resistance (i.e. where there are few people around or landmarks that would get in my way when using a cane -- such as portable folding signs that are placed in the middle of a sidewalk).
5. being able to safely guide me to a stop after approaching a wheelchair ramp so i don't accidentally veer into traffic when i'm walking fast.
6. stopping on a dime after seeing a car pull out in front of me or alongside of me when making a turn.
7. i don't have to worry about getting my cane caught in sidewalk cracks and painfully jabbing me in the stomach.
8. having people walk up to me and start conversations by telling me what a beautiful dog i have or asking me how she is trained.
9. being able to cross streets independently even though i can't hear (pre-CI).
10. being able to maintain a somewhat straight line of travel in the snow (depending on how deep it is) without veering.
11. i feel safer traveling at night with a dog for my own protection.
advantages of using the long cane:
1. being able to use the constant contact technique to gain information about the ground underneath my feet. i can do the same with my guide dog by paying attention to cues on the ground, but it's easier interpreting and understanding them when using a cane.
2. being able to have constant contact with landmarks and other objects that are in my path. with a guide dog, the dog goes around obstacles meaning that i could miss a landmark if i'm not paying close attention.
3. not having people constantly asking if they can pet my guide dog.
4. being able to fold my cane away when not in use. (i obviously can't do that with a guide dog!) there have been times where poor sugar and tigger have been stepped on -- especially when riding public transportation.
5. most people recognize that a cane means blindness or visual impairment. they don't ask me, "is that a blind dog?" or "are you training that dog?"
6. not having to take my cane out to do her business when the weather is cold, rainy, icy or snowy outside.
7. being able to tell the depth of a snowbank by using three point touch or running my cane along the top of it.
8. being able to locate stairs with ease. with a guide dog, the dog hesitates at the top of a staircase, but sometimes i walk so fast that i'm not paying attention to what tigger is doing. with a cane, i never miss stairs because i can immediately feel my cane drop when it locates a step.