However, yes,
My apologies to Rebecca for taking a part in derailing her thread.
many, many sorry! from me, Rebecca
I beg your forgiveness.
Hope things with daughter are Okay on the ASL subject?
Is she going to learn the sing language for you, I hope?
Fuzzy
She is already great singer. She win lots of sing language contests.
got hearing aides for work, the first comment my own mother say is, "Well, I hope you don't let anyone see them."
I will *still* require ASL to communicate (or pen/paper) audiogram or no audiogram. She flat out refuses to do both so how do we communicate?
I do not think you understand. My daughter and I are best buddies. Very, very close. Even her own best friends come to me for advice and support, instead of their own parents, so must be doing something right.
This is *ONLY* area that she seem defensive about. She is amazing, smart and beautiful young woman. Feel lucky that have such amazing daughter.
Plus, I *know* she hates my broken English, written or verbal. I explain to her how challenging it has always been to speak/write in sentences. She just hates it and, moreso in this last year, expressing more anger about that. I give her links to information, to educate her, but she is impatient with it. My older two daughters *get* it and my son's (16) comments are, "Mum, I already *know* that!
Maybe she is expressing resentment for the times that I *needed* her help?
Interesting you mention bolded because boyfriend and I have talk this morning and he say same thing. I cannot remember if ever tell youngest what own mother like to me. Hurts too much to talk and then I start crying when I discuss subject but maybe *need* to so they understand better? Think only ever tell them that my mother should never have been mother.
Sorry. I didn't knew that,
and in all this commotion I missed that, too, because
at the beginning I got from some posts that she wanted to learn sign language at 14,
and others also mentioned your daughter needs to learn sign language and finger-spelling -
so it stayed with me that she doesn't know it yet, sorry.
I was wondering if your mother instilled in you deep sense of being ashamed of being H-o-H/deaf, guilty even,
and thus feeling responsible for being understood rather than being understood to?
Well, how important for you is that your daughter communicate in ASL?
Are you willing to stop communicating at all if it is not ASL or pen/paper?
If you are determined to put your foot down, are you prepared for possible tears and emotional turmoil?
Obviously, you are a great mother, and more than that - not only you are
a great mother, you are being a great mentor to your daughter's friends, too!
and that is helluva achievement~!
well, daughter - TOUGH.
She needs to shut up about this already.
If she hates it, maybe she should think how much YOU hate it-
to be the person who has trouble with speech, with written/spoken English, being constantly corrected, constantly asked to repeat yourself,
and bear the brunt of those like your daughter which btw hurt the most, doesn't it? etc -
in other words - did she ever tried to walk in YOUR shoes for a change?
who the heck she thinks she is?!
Well, express it once and for all and move on.
Besides, you didn't do anything so horrible it can not be gotten over already.
Did you apologize? I'll bet you did.
So what else would she expect? Lifetime supply of newest technological gadgets ?
Plenty of deaf parents use their children as their "ears" and hardly anybody
is traumatized.
While I am not condoning the use of hearing children as "ears" for the deaf
parents, it has its good side, too - the children often learn early how to be assertive
and resourceful because of that. So it's not all evil.
I think this is good idea regardless of anything.
It is usually good for the children to know something intimate about their parents,
however I am not too sure if this will help any with the issue you have with your daughter not wanting use ASL with you.
It may, then again it may not. You should know.
I think the only thing that will matter in the end is how determined you are
for your daughter to use ASL with you.
For this, you need to resolve within yourself how much you and your needs are important, if you will stand up for you as a deaf person, and proceed from there.
You mentioned your daughter is in college now.
I wondered if her college offers any ASL courses, or anything having to
do with deafness that would be useful to you? maybe that would help?
Maybe she will be willing to participate in that, and this will broaden her horizons.
I know how much it hurts when the people you love most hurt you like that.
I feel for you.
But she is still very young, and simply still very inexperienced.
With firm guidance, she'll get it some day.
And you, Mom -you got everybody's back here
Fuzzy
well, daughter - TOUGH.
She needs to shut up about this already.
If she hates it, maybe she should think how much YOU hate it-
to be the person who has trouble with speech, with written/spoken English, being constantly corrected, constantly asked to repeat yourself,
and bear the brunt of those like your daughter which btw hurt the most, doesn't it? etc -
in other words - did she ever tried to walk in YOUR shoes for a change?
who the heck she thinks she is?!
Oh, and she text me from University tonight, "I have such a bad fever wish I had Mum to take care of me." Breaks my heart that I cannot tuck her in bed with homemade chicken noodle soup. How can you be upset with daughter who like this?
Yes, you are right about quote from my own Mum. Make me cry re-reading that. I don't know why because grown woman now and that several year ago. But it break my heart when she say to me that. Always, *ALWAYS* ashamed deaf. Always, *ALWAYS* ashame not speak right for Mum. She always embarrass for me speak in front of stranger. Would stand close beside her and her arm would always come down as in 'stop' as in 'don't say anything let me speak for you.'
Part of me feel *SO* guilty for thinking 'shut up about it already' but another part make me wonder why, she of all babies, think this way. She *SO* philosopher and want be forensic psychiatrist. Why someone who want, so clearly to study human mind, do not want to study Mummy?
God you make me cry.[waaaa] You touch hurts with your words because how I feel. Exactly! SO sick of correcting speech. So sick of other correcting my speech...ESPECIALLY HER!!! She do it A LOT!! And, you right, it hurts SO much coming from her because she *SO* premature and I love her SO desperately. I stay all time with her at hospital so hope she do not die because too early born. Begging her to fight for life while nurses keep rushing over for apparent beeping and whatever happen. Begging her to not have mental or physical problem. To beat odd. Then beg her to just stay alive and do not care what come with that. Just want baby to live. Go through rollercoaster with her when she born. A month of staring into plastic incubator will do that to Mumma. Mumma who think normal to just bring baby home from hospital after a couple days. Cannot do with this daughter or son after her.
I *DO* think she may be resentful for feeling like she is adult in relationship for sometime because I ask her help to hear for me. BUT, I bring subject up here and STOP immediately. Talk to babies and tell sorry, should not ever ask you do this, did not realize how rely on them and so sorry and will not do again. Think she 'mother hen' personality and, maybe, she miss being the one that Mumma always ask, "What they say? What was that?"
Thing that bothers me is *this* daughter *FIRST* child to want to know ASL. Do not understand what change. Maybe is because do not always rely on it in daily life? Maybe because do not go voice off threat? Maybe she fine thinking she do not have to use ASL for everyday and now scared because she feel do not know enough of language to communicate to Mumma.
Honestly, knowing my darling girl, I do not think she meant it to come across the way it came across. She very blunt (don't know where she get that from ) but she also just little girl inside sometimes.
She probably, because grow up Deaf Mum recent, she know 'blunt' better than most hearie kids. Will forgive her for bluntness. Will not accept that she refuse learn my language because her language also. She do not know as much as me but she was very fascinated by it which helped me to unleash my identity..knowing I have children who accept my first language.
It could be your daughter wants to be selfish right now and not have every visit with you be all about you and your needs for ASL (from her perspective).
She is still very, very young, and really we can't expect her to act like an adult at her age. Developmentally, she just isn't able. But that doesn't mean that you have to tolerate disrespect from her, either.
At this age, it is normal for things to be "all about me." That is why I suggested at the very beginning that you turn it around on her so she was the one being asked for proof of something. Demonstrating how the same thing could have a negative effect on her is the quickest way to realization when you are talking about 18-25 year olds.
Funny thing is that the kids appreciate mom when mom isn't there to help. We get taken for granted. In a way, it means that we've done our job. The kids were secure and knew that mom would always be there. That's why Rebecca got that text.
rebeccaj - three years ago, I asked one of my sisters (I have three sisters, all older than me) why her other sister got invited to her parties but I never did. Her response was that when she was in her 20s, she wanted to be selfish for she felt as though growing up, her life revolved around me and my deafness, that I got the lion's share of my mother's attention. As she got old enough to move out of the house, she wanted her life to be all about herself for a change. She didn't invite me because, in her words, she didn't want to worry about babysitting me at her parties and making sure I was having a good time. She wanted to be able to relax and not have to worry.
That was very educational for me and really helped strengthen our bonds. it made me realize that the issue wasn't that I wasn't good enough, it was that she needed some time to be utterly selfish for a while.
It could be your daughter wants to be selfish right now and not have every visit with you be all about you and your needs for ASL (from her perspective).
It's obvous from the text message she sent you that she loves and adores you very much and is having a hard time balancing between being selfish and being considerate and respectful of your needs.
Give her time to grow up. Your other kids got it, but this one may need a little more time before she gets it too. But don't let her attitude make you feel guilty in any way and certainly don't let every single thing she says send you into an emotional tailspin. Just ride it out, keep on being yourself, be mature and in control and she will come around.
Hey, no need to thank me I didn't do anything
I can sense you are hurting deeply, it's palpable from your posts.
The thing about our parents is it doesn't matter how old we get,
if they are alive or dead, we will always always remember the pain they've caused us and mourn what we wanted them, needed them to be
but they never were.
This strike a common chord here with me although on different matters,
and it occurred to me - perhaps because such treatment made you feel dismissed, small, insignificant,
stupid even?
I know it would make me feel like that.
Your mom didn't understood your deaf nature, and that is very sad.
I have this theory it's not that she didn't want to,
it's just her generation was too conservative to know any better.
It does hurt very, very VERY much for she was your mom and if anything,
looks like she should have support you, protected you, not do the other way.
And looks like she has failed at it.
I was wondering if you are mourning
her failing to understand you, and protect you in your deafness, or you mourn more what never happened- her supporting you as a deaf child, and later a deaf adult and being happy for you in this?
It may take you a number of years, but when the right time comes
you will be able to forgive your mom and move on, I assure you...
It does help to talk about it, so if you have someone to talk, please, do.
well, from my experience we moms come last, lolol
we are the safest pple in the world - we are always here, always dependable,
always accepting, good to dump everything on our heads
oh, and we were never young, we don't know what love is, and we never ever have s-e-x !
I am so sorry, I didn't mean to make you cry..
I just thought how would I feel, and I would feel very hurt, rejected even,
if someone I care deeply for wouldn't bother to be more considerate for me in return.
Especially in something so basic and important, my livelihood, really.
And especially you, seeing how you give everything of yourself and more to this baby, and she seems so selfish, right?
Perhaps this whole issue is all the harder to bear for you because it feels like it's your mother allover again?
It seems like "what the hey, is your own daughter turning into your mother despite all you went thru, or what?"
What can hurt more than your very blood and flesh
turning into your mother, right?
But I don't think that's the case- I think maybe your daughter just lack
a maturity needed to grasp the concept of what it REALLY mean to be deaf and communicate with hearing pple,
let alone how important it is to you
from the mother-daughter perspective, is all.
Well, if she misses being "momma hen" and translating for you,
then all the more reason to learn better ASL and communicate with you only thru it
But, frankly, pardon for being so blunt, who cares what they think- too much?
It's you and what you need what's important in this matter.
No, I know you feel hurt by your daughter refusal, but also why would you care "why"?
She's only 18, 14, 16, 18, 20- they change all the time,
in a few years from now she sure is not going to think what is she thinking today,
and you are still her guidance and influence, her PARENT.
Great parent
Do not doubt yourself.
Exactly! so you know her
hmmm, at 18 she is just probably discovering her own identity and she is yet going to change her mind hundred times over.
Does the other children sign with you?
And last but not least - what do you mean by "unleash my identity?"
Do you mean you weren't forthcoming as a deaf person in your own family at first, if you don't mind me asking?
Fuzzy
Probably moreso 'palpable' because father have quadruple bypass surgery the other day so thoughts of parent at surface. So have hurting and sad and worry for him.
Yes, oldest daughter and her kids sign with me. We use combination of sign and speaking. 2nd daughter is going to learn ASL. Youngest two kids know lots of signs and even though son is, how say, on the fence, he signs while he talks to me sometimes but I do not think he realizes he is doing it.
When say 'unleash my identity' probably proper word is 'embrace.' I grow up as 'pretend hearie.' Grow up to be embarrass to admit deaf. Family all know, of course, but expected to be hearie. Wake up one day and realize fraud and do not want to be living like that anymore so start journey toward being me. This began about 14 years ago. But, feel ashamed to be blunt about it at first. Still oral deaf with kids. Was like living two lives. 'Pretend hearie' Rebecca and Deaf Rebecca.
14 children and I was only child to get a degree but did not stop there. Needed more than one or two to prove to her was not fluke.
You give too much credit for her. She knew enough to leave me at hospital when born. Too much of burden for her.
Oh, have few years of weekly therapy, twice weekly if talk to her that week, but this also beginning of embrace Deaf me. So, on one hand forgive her for just being human, capable of mistake, but since find AD realize much more to it, if make sense? Is as though on road to truly understanding the magnitude of what she did.
Irresistably funny and absurd. That isn't the compliment you seem to think it is.
Oh, I am so very sorry! Quadruple surgery is no little thing, it's a big surgery.
How is he the post-op? Is he healing well?
I found this site you may find interesting:
My Quadruple Bypass
I hope your Daddy is doing well.
That is so nice
I see. Awww. I was wondering if you can tell me what prompted you to decide to stop hiding anymore from being yourself?
And how old were your oldest children, and your Baby Girl?
Did your mom ever acknowledged your achievements, if I may ask?
I am so sorry, I can't believe that
That is a vile, hardhearted thing that she did. How could she left her baby!
But she did came back for you? was she never nice, warm for you?
again, if you don't mind me asking this.
I am very glad you had (have?) therapy. Sounds like something you very much needed with mom like that.
but since find AD realize much more to it, if make sense? - it makes perfect sense!
Yes, the magnitude of what she did was significant- she was killing the essence of you.
True, I don't know your mom, - but, please don't think of her as someone evil who broke your spirit - because you are Deaf Rebecca soaring now
So, no, no broken spirit here, you were too strong, and you could very well inherit the strength trait from her, want it or not,
like it or not
If I can give you a suggestion, for I had own issues with my own family as well.
I learned you can't change the past. Period.
I learned I need to fully accept that someone, sometime was an flat out mean wrong, there is nothing deeper than that,
and that's it.
I learned that I have to disassociate my "I" , "me" from that person,
and ever since I was able to look at the past without so much emotion and pain anymore.
It was so freeing!
I was able to move on for the first time in my life!
And TRULY forgive.
And your daughter is NOT your mom. She is she.
Look at your daughter with fresh eyes, and the issue will be so much easier
to deal with
Fuzzy
The lady doth protest too much, methinks.
<< not reading thesises