Row over Bible removal
The World Today Archive - Tuesday, 29 May , 2001 00:00:00
Reporter: Lachlan Parker
ELEANOR HALL: In the city of churches, there's a row over Bibles. Two hotels in Adelaide have caused dismay among religious groups by taking Gideon's Bibles out of guest rooms. The local managers of the international Stamford chain argue the Bibles should go because Australia is a multicultural society.
But the Gideons who've spent almost a century placing nearly one billion Bibles in hotels say they're disappointed by the decision and will pray over it. Lachlan Parker reports from Adelaide.
LACHLAN PARKER: There are a few ways you can tell you're in a hotel room, the chocolate on the pillow, the mini bar and the Bible in the top drawer. The Gideons is an organisation of Christian lay people who since 1908 have been placing Bibles in hotel and motel rooms around the world, as well as hospitals, nursing homes and prisons.
Gideons executive director, Trevor Monson.
TREVOR MONSON: Because we want people to have the opportunity to read the word of God.
LACHLAN PARKER: But that word will no longer be spread in the Stamford hotels in Adelaide because hotel management has decided it wants to reflect Australia's multi-faith society. So instead of Bibles in the drawers, a selection of religious volumes from various faiths will be at the front desk.
John Lewis, the general manager of the Hotels Association, has praised the move.
JOHN LEWIS: Well I think the hotels are displaying probably a progressive attitude. It's still going to be able to provide the Bible for its guests that stay in the hotel, but it's also going to provide a range of religious materials, because I think we should accept the fact that hotel guests who stay in our hotels across Australia today come from a broad range of backgrounds, and as a result, a broad range of religious beliefs.
So, the hotel's still going to provide the Bible, but it's going to provide a range of religious material, so I think it's quite a progressive move. I'm not sure whether it's going to be something that's going to be adopted by the rest of the hotel industry.
LACHLAN PARKER: Trevor Monson from the Gideons agrees the Stamford seems to be the only hotel moving away from the Bibles.
TREVOR MONSON: Well, the Gideons International operating in 175 countries around the world, many of which aren't Christian and they don't seem to have a problem with having Bibles in their hotels. We receive a constant stream of letters from people who have read the Bibles in hotels and are grateful for them being there.
LACHLAN PARKER: So you think they do have an impact?
TREVOR MONSON: My word they do. We know that from the stream of letters that comes in.
LACHLAN PARKER: What sort of things are said in those letters?
TREVOR MONSON: All sorts of situations, from people who thought they were doing just fine and had a read of the scriptures and were encouraged, to people who went to a hotel room with the intent of committing suicide and for some reason saw the Bible, picked it up, started to read it and decided that they would have another go at life.
LACHLAN PARKER: Adelaide's Anglican Archbishop, Ian George, is also the patron of the South Australian Multi-Faith Association, an umbrella group for the state's religions, Christian and non-Christian alike.
IAN GEORGE: Well I was surprised. I thought it was a well established custom, and certainly the majority of Australians regard themselves as Christians according to our census, the large majority, and I would have thought that this was probably a retrograde step.
LACHLAN PARKER: But what about the argument that we're in a multicultural and multi-religious society, and that we shouldn't just be reflecting Christian beliefs?
IAN GEORGE: That's right, well that's true. But if you wanted, as I said, add material, then by all means do that. I just don't see the point in Australia in taking them away.
LACHLAN PARKER: Meanwhile, Trevor Monson from the Gideons says he's not going to fight the removal.
TREVOR MONSON: The reaction of the Gideons to a refusal to scriptures is simply to withdraw and pray about the situation.
ELEANOR HALL: Trevor Monson from Gideons ending Lachlan Parker's report.
http://www.abc.net.au/worldtoday/s304573.htm