Immigrant has octuplets; California taxpayers to cough up $2 Million
By Wing Chun Geologist on January 30, 2009 at 08:31 pm No Comments Yet
Immigrant has octuplets; California taxpayers to cough up $2 Million
Usually when a woman has septuplets or octuplets, it makes the news big time. The story is treated as an amazing accomplishment by the mother, and tremendous blessing to the parents and society as a whole. Seldomly does the media follow up on the health problems experienced by the children, such as cerebral palsy. Less frequently still does the media look at the cost. In most cases the medical care for large births like that run about $250,000 per child, and the taxpayer foots the bill.
Mark Perloe, MD and E. Scott Sills, MD, of the Atlanta Reproductive Health Center, say that no one likes to count pennies when it comes to health care, especially for premature babies, but these multiple births are accompanied by huge expenses. Doctors caring for the octuplets born in Houston in 1998 estimated the babies’ care cost at least $2 million (about $250,000 per infant) before they even went home. Add the likely expenses for providing ongoing medical care after the babies left the hospital, and the cost quickly soared into the millions.
Even so, the media is usually all over the story when a woman has 7 or 8 babies. That’s why the news blackout of the recent octuplets born in Bellflower, CA created its own news sensation. Who was the mother? Who was the father? Reporter and news consumers wanted to know, mostly because that information was being withheld.
As reporters for KFI radio in Los Angeles began looking into the story, several facts emerged. The mother has six other children and reportedly was on some form of public assistance. The local CBS affiliate has reported that the family involved had filed for bankruptcy and abandoned a home last year. KFI has reported a number of items about the mother:
1. She is a Middle Eastern Immigrant
2. Her parents may be from Iraq
3. She is on public assistance
4. She is not married to the biological father, although he is the father of her other children.
5. The biological father is “happily” married to someone else, and has a family with his wife.
6. The mother refused to selectively terminate any of the fetuses she was carrying.
7. The pregnancy was definitely planned.
8. The mother’s parents have hired a private investigator.
9. The PI has been telling neighbors and friends not to talk to the media.
Much of the media coverage has been on the issue of what fertility treatments the mother might have had leading to the pregnancy. The probability of a woman having octuplets without fertility treatment is a near statistical impossibility.
The chances that the eight babies born Monday were conceived naturally are infinitesimal, infertility specialists and doctors in maternal-fetal medicine say. Today’s reproductive experts have the tools and the know-how to avoid such high-risk pregnancies — and often try desperately to do so.
Ethical fertility specialists will usually do all they can to avoid large multiple births. It is dangerous for a woman to try and carry so many babies, and even more dangerous for the babies themselves.
While all eight of the Bellflower infants were listed in “stable” condition, two were placed on ventilators because of breathing problems. And a “stable” diagnosis guarantees next to nothing in terms of how they will be faring tomorrow, or five or 10 years hence. Premature babies account for more than half of all infants who do not survive the first year of life. Those who do survive often encounter problems ranging from blindness and feedingproblems to cerebral palsy and long-term developmental disabilities.
In most “tuplet” cases, fertility treatment is involved.
It is no coincidence that premature births in this country have risen at the same time that more women are undergoing fertility treatments. According to the National Center for Health Statistics, the rate of preterm births in the United States—defined as birth at less than 37 completed weeks of gestation—has risen by 36% since the early 1980s. Nearly 536,000 babies were born too soon in 2006.
One of the main reasons for the growing number of preterm births is a high number of births of twins and “higher-order multiples,” all of which are more likely to come into the world too soon. Triplet-and-higher births increased nearly fivefold from 1980 to 1998 before leveling off over the last decade, and experts attribute the bulk of the rise to “assisted reproduction.”
In the case of the Bellflower octuplets, the hospital wouldn’t say whether the mother had been using fertility drugs—but most experts consulted by the media say there is little doubt that she had. The octuplets’ births are just the latest in a series of high-profile births of octuplets, septuplets and sextuplets presumably made possible by fertility treatments. Many of these babies did not survive.
While many are looking at this as an issue that raises questions about the practice of fertility doctors, I believe that it also throws up red flags about socialized medicine. When something is free, some people will take advantage of the system. The state of California is destitute, and the decisions made by this mother and her happily-married-to-someone-else sperm provider will cost the state millions of dollars by the time all the babies go home. It is highly likely that some of those babies will require expensive ongoing medical care, as well as expensive special education classes. It is too early to even calculate the total cost to the California taxpayer