Should Elephants Perform In Circuses?

Angel

♥"Concrete Angel"♥
Premium Member
Joined
Nov 28, 2003
Messages
19,059
Reaction score
6
It's a simple question that's caused a lot of controversy over the years....At the heart of the matter are allegations by animal-welfare activists that brutal training methods are used to coerce elephants—which can weigh as much as 8,000 pounds (3,600 kilograms)—into performing tricks such as headstands.

Elephants and Laws

Under the U.S. Endangered Species Act, the African elephant is listed as a threatened species, and the Asian elephant is listed as an endangered species.

"Endangered" means a species is considered in danger of extinction throughout all or a significant portion of its range. "Threatened" means a species is considered in danger of becoming endangered.

This protection prohibits elephant parts and products from being imported into the United States, except under certain conditions.

In addition, elephants are protected under the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES), an agreement among more than 120 nations to eliminate illegal trade in animals and plants, such as elephants, and their parts and associated products. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service is the federal agency responsible for the U.S. government's compliance with the CITES treaty.

The African Elephant Conservation Act of 1988 prohibits the import of raw or worked ivory into the U.S., with certain exceptions. It also set up a grant program to fund elephant conservation efforts.

In June 1989, the U.S. government imposed a ban on commercial importation of African elephant ivory into the country. This led to a commercial ivory trade ban being adopted by all CITES member nations later in 1989.

Source: U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service


Some three dozen communities in 15 U.S. states ban, restrict, or regulate animal performances. Localities that have banned circuses, rodeos, and other animal acts include Stamford, Connecticut; Hollywood, Florida, Boulder, Colorado, and Pasadena, California.....

Elephant Abuse Charges Add Fuel to Circus Debate
 
Yeah, I do believe that Elephants shouldn't be in circus because I've seen people got killed by elephants when they are abuse. I've seen elephants being chained by two feet, Why do they have to lead a miserable life? Let them be elephants, They should not be owned by anyone. Animals don't have a voice like us tell us when they are hurting, that's why elephants ran out of the circus and hurt other people, because of trust, Elephants don't trust anyone because how they were treated. That's one reason why I don't go to the circus anymore.
 
I don't go circus. OFC I get heartbroken when animals being abused. I hate them.
 
I don't know if you saw this on TV but there was a man who had hidden camera and pretend he was working in the circus, and after seeing the video from the camera how the elephants were being treat by using whips and chains, hitting with stick etc....It was horrible, I never thought those people who works for the circus will mistreat these animals in order for them to do a show....


After I saw what happened, I wouldn't take my children to the circus anymore....
 
If I pretended to work at circus, I would release them free and let them stomp all over the cruel people who hurt the elephants. (I wish) I hate people abusing animals, that's really sick!
 
Maybe your wish will come true sequoias! :P
 
i HATE seeing animals in circus.. they dont belong to circus.. they should stay in their own wildlife.

we should see Cirque Du Soleil more often ! the acrobats performances are tooooooo beautiful and very artistic.
 
Last edited:
Hmmmm, these people move around from state to state and maybe there's lack of registration/enforcement or budget shortages, etc, etc of the various states?
 
I personally dislike the circuses featuring animals because of the brutal abuse toward them.

I never go to any, I suggest that people boycott it.
 
I do not mind taking my wife when I have one with the kids to a circus as long as the animals are not mistreated, are healthy and well fed, taken good care of.
 
Heath said:
I do not mind taking my wife when I have one with the kids to a circus as long as the animals are not mistreated, are healthy and well fed, taken good care of.

That's the problem... there's no such a circus where the animals aren't being mistreated.
 
Heath said:
I do not mind taking my wife when I have one with the kids to a circus as long as the animals are not mistreated, are healthy and well fed, taken good care of.


How do you really know that these people is not mistreating the animals when you don't know what's going on behind the circus....
 
I love elephants but hate circus. It goes same for zoo, they trapped wild animals and brought them to USA for show and tell, heart break for me to see them in cages when they should be free in wild.
 
jazzy said:
It goes same for zoo, they trapped wild animals and brought them to USA for show and tell, heart break for me to see them in cages when they should be free in wild.

I didn't think the animals at the zoo are being mistreated, I've seen them being proper taken care of, providing food and being left alone not bothered. I love to see animals at the zoo expectly the chimps, They're cute! ;)
 
Banjo said:
That's the problem... there's no such a circus where the animals aren't being mistreated.

I am not brave enough to say ALL trainers abuse these animals. Sounds like an impossibility to me. I won't even ask you to prove it because I know you can't. Have some restraint in your assertions.
 
I don't think all of them do because there are people out there who works for the circus are animal lovers too and it doesn't mean every circus out there abused their animals....
 
Cheri said:
I didn't think the animals at the zoo are being mistreated, I've seen them being proper taken care of, providing food and being left alone not bothered. I love to see animals at the zoo expectly the chimps, They're cute! ;)


I don't think so either unless they have proof but I highly doubt it...
 
I used to like to go to a circus when I was a little girl but after reading stories about how the elephants and some other animals were mistreated I will not go back to another circus. I hate it when I see animals are being abused. They have feelings too just like us human beings do.
 
Back
Top