Shel, I dont think he made that statement referrign to CI as a fad. The way I understood hie post was different. I think he amy be referring to any resentment towards parents for not getting the CI. If a deaf student without a CI, looks at his peers and sees them talking on the phone, holding oral conversations, hearing effectively, the child may become angry with parents for not giving them that opportunity. As for the residual hearing being destroyed, that is an issue that may not be all that correct anymore. When the Freedom CI was created, they made the tip of the array rounded and kind of padded. Thereason they did this was to make the array insertion less damaging to the inside of the cochlea. Residual hearing was destroyed when the array was placed in the cochlea. The tip of the array was rigid and not rounded off. The result was the tip gouging the walls of teh cochlea and destroying any residual hearing. Therea re several users of teh freedom that report the ability to use their natural residual hearing after undergoing CI surgery with the Freedom CI. The other issue of preserving residual hearing deals with the drilling of the hole through the wall of teh cochlea. This causes some of the fluid in the cochlea to drain. If teh hole is placed higher up on the cochlea, the fluid level may be retained.
On a related note, I sat through a parents workshop at my daughters school. An Audi from Children Hospital was a guest speaker. One of the topics she discuused was soem of the things coming ion the near future with CI. One of the many things she discussed were some pretty cool ideas that may be coming soon in the field of preserving residual hearing. Soem of the ideas were taken from the succes of the soft, rounded tip of the freedom array, and also from advancements of the hybrid CI.
One of the cool things they are experimenting with is bettering the tip of the array in conjunction of certain drugs that they inject into the cochlea immediately after drilling into it to preserve the hairs. If I rememebr correctly, the drugs are similar to some tyopes of steroids. The drill the hole, inject the drug, insert the array, and let the scarring on the cochlea close it up. This way, you get a good insertion, miminal damage to the walls of the cochlea, and use of drugs to treat any damage that may occur during the procedure.