deafbajagal
New Member
- Joined
- Nov 6, 2007
- Messages
- 5,168
- Reaction score
- 5
RD, you wasn't talking about grass as in...(smoking) ...were, you?
RD, you wasn't talking about grass as in...(smoking) ...were, you?
RD, you wasn't talking about grass as in...(smoking) ...were, you?
rockdrummer - The sign that Cheri describes is the one that I have used in ASL. You are using SEE, right? There is a SEE dictionary, Signing Exact English, Gerilee Gustavson and Esther Zawolkow, published Modern Sign Press.
BINGO! That is the exact sign my son showed me. I don't think it is regional. I was trying to tell him I was going outside to cut the grass and I signed that to him in ASL. He looked at me confused when I signed grass in ASL. Then I showed him a picture of grass and he said no no.. and then showed me the claw sign up to his chin. Now that is confirmed the SEE sign for grass. People keep telling me that the SEE signs are the same as ASL but I find over and over that they are not. Personally I belive they should be and all the englishy stuff should have been appened to ASL.According to SEE II in Arkansas, it is a palm (5 fingers facing upward) on the chin, going up and down...kinda hard to explain.
That's a regional sign.
I'm sorry loml, the root signs are the same in some cases but there are many where they are not. Grass is a case in point. Also "what" is signed differently and I can think of many others.SEE uses signs from ASL, the modifications are used for representing the affixes, prefixes, suffixes and contractions used in English. The "root sign" remains the same.
For example: grasses = ASL sign for grass with a "s" handshape to represent the plural form - grasses.
Hope that helps.
uhm... no But if I were, what would the sign be. Just for reference purposes of course.RD, you wasn't talking about grass as in...(smoking) ...were, you?
Thank you loml. The problem is that I hate learning signs from a book. It's very difficult with some of the signs to figure out what the little drawings are trying to tell you. I love aslpro.com It makes ASL eaisly accessable. I wish there was a similar SEE site. I don't know. Maybe call it seepro.com. It makes me want to discuss another topic but perhaps I will start a thread about it.rockdrummer - The sign that Cheri describes is the one that I have used in ASL. You are using SEE, right? There is a SEE dictionary, Signing Exact English, Gerilee Gustavson and Esther Zawolkow, published Modern Sign Press.
This is an other good resource book: Signing Exact English Using Affixes, compiled by Billie McDavitt and Patrice Stephenson. It is a great resource that show "root sign" and the affixes, prefixes etc. I am pretty sure you can still get it through Modern Sign Press, Inc.
You're right...ASL and SEE are very different...some signs are the same but some are so different. True SEE does not use conceptually accurate signs...for example...
Butterfly would be sign as butter (the spread) + fly (as in airplane, flying.
I'm sorry loml, the root signs are the same in some cases but there are many where they are not. Grass is a case in point. Also "what" is signed differently and I can think of many others.
I'm a certified CDI...and I've been trained in SEE as well. That IS the sign for butterfly in true SEE form.
ptually accurate signs...for example...
Butterfly would be sign as butter (the spread) + fly (as in airplane, flying. Nowdays a lot of SEE users do use CASE (Conceptually Accurate Signed English) along with SEE...and some even use CVL (that's where some ASL signs would come in...called Contact Language Variety).
According to SEE II in Arkansas, it is a palm (5 fingers facing upward) on the chin, going up and down...kinda hard to explain.
That's a regional sign.
Originally Posted by deafbajagal
According to SEE II in Arkansas, it is a palm (5 fingers facing upward) on the chin, going up and down...kinda hard to explain.
That's a regional sign.
That is not the sign used on aslpro.com. Now I am really confused.That's the sign the Deaf community here in MD uses and it is part of the ASL vocabulary.