rockin'robin
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Apr 22, 2007
- Messages
- 24,431
- Reaction score
- 549
Oklahoma State Senator Mark Allen is supporting a bill that proposes chemical castration of violent sex offenders. California and Florida have already implemented similar laws.
The proposal would allow first time violent sex offenders the option of voluntary castration in return for an early release date from prison. Chemical castration would be mandatory for second time offenders.
David Slane, an attorney who has represented more than 500 sex offenders, thinks chemical castration would help in rehabilitating sex offenders
He explained, “I remember one in particular who told me he went to his doctor voluntarily. He used this hormone therapy and, as he said, 'It cured me. I no longer have the thoughts. I no longer have the sex drive.' For years afterwards he had never reoffended. So to me, that was proof in the pudding. There may be something here."
However, Slane also realizes there are shortcomings to the proposed law. He said, “On the other hand, the idea that we would force drugs on people that have not been approved by the FDA would subject the state to lawsuits, and I feel like that part needs to be taken out.”
Senator Allen also has seen the results from other states. He said, “The inmate has to go through counseling before going through the process. I think they've had about a 90 percent success rate. If somebody wants an early release from prison they can go through the process."
Similar to Oklahoma’s proposal, Florida and California have mandatory castration for repeat sex offenders. If passed, the law could take effect in November.
http://www.opposingviews.com/i/poli...ing-chemical-castration-violent-sex-offenders
The proposal would allow first time violent sex offenders the option of voluntary castration in return for an early release date from prison. Chemical castration would be mandatory for second time offenders.
David Slane, an attorney who has represented more than 500 sex offenders, thinks chemical castration would help in rehabilitating sex offenders
He explained, “I remember one in particular who told me he went to his doctor voluntarily. He used this hormone therapy and, as he said, 'It cured me. I no longer have the thoughts. I no longer have the sex drive.' For years afterwards he had never reoffended. So to me, that was proof in the pudding. There may be something here."
However, Slane also realizes there are shortcomings to the proposed law. He said, “On the other hand, the idea that we would force drugs on people that have not been approved by the FDA would subject the state to lawsuits, and I feel like that part needs to be taken out.”
Senator Allen also has seen the results from other states. He said, “The inmate has to go through counseling before going through the process. I think they've had about a 90 percent success rate. If somebody wants an early release from prison they can go through the process."
Similar to Oklahoma’s proposal, Florida and California have mandatory castration for repeat sex offenders. If passed, the law could take effect in November.
http://www.opposingviews.com/i/poli...ing-chemical-castration-violent-sex-offenders
