jillio
New Member
- Joined
- Jun 14, 2006
- Messages
- 60,232
- Reaction score
- 19
It is, otherwise, all deaf people would be using SEE while conversing. I just cant imagine that happening but if some peope want to change ASL to SEE, by all means go for it. I will just continue with ASL cuz I understand it much better than SEE and my friends and co workers (both hearing and deaf) say the same about SEE. PSE is much more common than SEE and it follows English more closely than ASL does. If u feel more comfortable signing in SEE, who am I to tell u what to do. I prefer deaf children acquire their language through the appropriate languages not thru a visual code of a language and then use whatever tools they feel they can benefit from to help them with reading and writing.
PSE incorporates some of the features of ASL and therefore translates to the visual much better than SEE, but is stillnot as comprehensible--on a visual/spatial level as ASL. Think of it this way and see if you argree with me shel...you can understand and converse in ASL without ever actually putting anything into an English word, and still have full undertanding of the communication. It doesn't require an English word symbol to be understood, you can undertand the messange in its own right on a visual spatiallevel.