I read all three letters of application and resumes in addition to reading half the posts on this thread, before trying to evaluate the candidates for myself. The intended target (audience) was the Board of Trustee. I could tell Jane Fernandes made her application and resume very thorough and clear-cut, but seemingly indifferent towards deaf people. It made it harder to understand her real motives, unlike the other two candidates.
I feel it is imperative and equally important that Gallaudet students feel a connection towards their president, even if the President's job does not require making decisions alluding from the students opinions. Gallaudet is unique in that it's the first university in the world (to my knowledge) to have a deaf president; and having a deaf/HOH President that shows enthusiasm for deaf people and fully understands their needs is just as important as the ability to deal with the stress load.
In Ron Stern's application and resume, it seemed he could connect to and understand deaf people's needs better than Jane--because he exhibited he has an "inside" understanding of deaf culture as indicated in his background at the California Schools for the Deaf. His tone in his presentation appeared more diplomatic and understanding towards deaf people. That is an important strength. Jane Fernandes, however, has 10 years of experience as Gallaudet Vice-President and Provost and that may have given the Board of Trustee reason to like her more because she has experience in how things are run at Gallaudet University from the adminstrative branch of government.
While going over the resumes of both Ron and Jane--one thing I found was how Ron had worked at the California Schools for the Deaf as teacher and principal, as well as coach; while Jane had worked with Associations for the Deaf, Deaf Centers, etc--which are "mostly administrative functions". Ron has both "inside" and "administrative" experience having worked at schools for the deaf--he previously served as Director of Instruction at CSD-Freemont, and Director of Athletics at Gallaudet (after having experience as basketball and football coach at two California Schools for the Deaf). Ron seems like a better candidate in favor of representation for deaf people.
Jane, on the other hand, has divided her application into very well organized, specific sections. She has shown that she will be very efficient when "getting down to business". She may even be better at it than the other candidates. But will she be understanding of deaf people? From her application, I could not tell because of her indifferent tone. As a result, I would have gone for Ron Stern in the best interests of deaf people.