Deaf woman sues hospital for not providing interpreter

Miss-Delectable

New Member
Joined
Apr 18, 2004
Messages
17,164
Reaction score
6
http://www.tuscaloosanews.com/apps/...1/APN/509010732&cachetime=3&template=dateline

A deaf woman is suing a hospital for not providing her with a sign language interpreter during child birth.

In her lawsuit filed Wednesday, Lisa Monique Webb alleges that St. Francis Medical Center in suburban Lynwood violated her civil rights under state law, according to a statement from the Western Law Center for Disability Rights, which is representing Webb.

The absence of a sign language interpreter made Webb's Caesarean section and subsequent stay at the hospital in December 2003 a fearful and frustrating experience because she did not understand what was happening to her or her newborn daughter, according to the law center.

"In a hospital, silence is not golden," Michelle Inouye Schultz, an attorney representing Webb, said in a statement. "It is critical that deaf patients be able to communicate with their doctors and nurses about their medical history, symptoms and prognosis."

The lawsuit also seeks a court order requiring St. Francis and its parent company, Daughters of Charity Health System, to train their employees about laws mandating effective communication for deaf people.

The hospital's attorney, Stephen H. Zell of Tustin, said through his secretary that he couldn't comment.

Linda Woo, a St. Francis spokeswoman, said the hospital has a policy of not commenting on pending litigation.

According to the law center, Webb, a single mother, alerted the hospital a week before she was admitted that she was deaf and repreatedly requested an interpreter after she was admitted.

St. Francis provided her with an interpreter for 15 minutes prior to her Caesarean but not during the operation or the following three days, the complaint says.

From the fourth through seventh days of her stay, an interpreter visited Webb once a day, according to the complaint.

"I never want what happened to me to happen to anyone else who is deaf," Webb said in a statement.
 
That is hilarious! I had 5 children WITHOUT an interpreter of any kind, at the hospital or doctor's, or anywhere. And I survived. Childbirth is a natural happening, not a disease.

Now, if you are in the hospital possibly dying with a dreaded disease, that is entirely different. In my time, a close relative would have been allowed in to comfort the deaf person and SOME doctors and nurses were willing to write notes. But now that the ADA Law is in effect there is no excuse.
 
stupid?

was this woman stupid?????????? :stupid:
way did she not get a pen and paper? a lap top? her freeking side kick?type dont send!
i do not feel sorry for deaf people who do not think!

like it or not ,if you are deaf you are missing 20% for your senses.. ergo,you need to use your brain more!!!!!!!!!!! :dance:

thank god i am a lesbian trapped in a mans body!!!
 
Lantana said:
That is hilarious! I had 5 children WITHOUT an interpreter of any kind, at the hospital or doctor's, or anywhere. And I survived. Childbirth is a natural happening, not a disease.

Now, if you are in the hospital possibly dying with a dreaded disease, that is entirely different. In my time, a close relative would have been allowed in to comfort the deaf person and SOME doctors and nurses were willing to write notes. But now that the ADA Law is in effect there is no excuse.

You are a truly tough cookie...
 
I find that Western Law Center for Disability Rights doing this case a bit odd.

5 yrs ago when my then-wife had gall bladder removal surgery, they provided interpreter before the surgery, afterwards they didnt and there was a lot of different people talking to both of us and we couldnt understand a thing.

The case we had pretty much mirrors this particular case that Western Law Center for Disability Rights is taking.

The question is why didnt Western Law Center for Disability Rights accept my ex-wife's case when we asked them for help?

Richard
 
that not right! but she is WRONG!

if i have baby but can hired interpreter to the hospital if hospital would approve for interpreter to explain to birth mothers!

i dont think i would cant sues to hospital i dont think so! but i can hire to interpreter or interpreter come see me to the hospital without warrants! or without statement

i knew many deaf mother can hired interpreter to any hospital what mother needs for birth of baby.

if i have c-section my mom would go with me in c-section because i had sezuire and my mom is nurse! and my mom would fill out my medical history and lots of more!

Sara Boyce
 
Lantana said:
... Childbirth is a natural happening, not a disease.
True. However, in this case, the mom was having a C-section, which is more complicated than vaginal birth. She might have had other additional medical factors. I got the impression from the story that her C-section was a scheduled one, not emergency, so the hospital had plenty of time to arrange for the terp.

Note writing works well for people who are on the same literacy level. Not every doctor knows how to write clear notes in elementary layman English. I have interpreted in medical settings, and word-for-word translations just don't cut it for many Deaf clients.

Some Deaf moms go to the hospital expecting a simple, natural delivery of a healthy baby. Maybe they don't need a terp. But, there is always the potential for something to quickly go wrong during delivery. The mom might have to make quick life-or-death decisions. It is much better to have the terp there, ready without delay. If doctors were smart, they would realize having the terp present is more protection for them against malpractice charges. A cheap expense compared to costly litigation.

IMHO :)
 
Today, while I was driving home from work, I heard a local radio station "talk" show discussing this story. The host was totally against the woman. He wanted to know where was the woman's husband? Then he said that Deaf women are "skanks" and sleep around. Whoa!

Anyway, I wrote a hot email to him as soon as I got home. I am trying to get a transcript of his program. If I do, I will post it.
 
Was this a basic talk radio program? Or what sort? That is just outright ridiculous.
 
Reba said:
Today, while I was driving home from work, I heard a local radio station "talk" show discussing this story. The host was totally against the woman. He wanted to know where was the woman's husband? Then he said that Deaf women are "skanks" and sleep around. Whoa!

Anyway, I wrote a hot email to him as soon as I got home. I am trying to get a transcript of his program. If I do, I will post it.

Rush Limbaugh Talkshow?
portraits.Par.0030.PortraitImageFile.gif
 
Excuse me, I´m speechless after read this thread here...

I do not NEED interpreter when I´m busy to give the birth to my children... I have C-Section on first child and natural birth to my 2nd son with NO interpreter...

Is it necassary to demand interpreter ... I has NO time to watch interpreter but need my hubby´s support and too busy to get my babies out to world...

I remember that some of threads in other forum mentioned how they need interpreter for childbirth... I really see no necassary... I never see anyone in my life to demand interpreter for childbirth...until other forum of last year and then here again for 2nd time...


A deaf woman is suing a hospital for not providing her with a sign language interpreter during child birth.

What a joking... :eek:
 
Liebling:-))) said:
Excuse me, I´m speechless after read this thread here...

I do not NEED interpreter when I´m busy to give the birth to my children... I have C-Section on first child and natural birth to my 2nd son with NO interpreter...

Is it necassary to demand interpreter ... I has NO time to watch interpreter but need my hubby´s support and too busy to get my babies out to world...

I remember that some of threads in other forum mentioned how they need interpreter for childbirth... I really see no necassary... I never see anyone in my life to demand interpreter for childbirth...until other forum of last year and then here again for 2nd time...




What a joking... :eek:

Deaf patient has a right to request. There is nothing what hospitals have to do but wait for the interpreters. If they did not request right away, they are in trouble...

Hospital provides us ASL interpeters. We do not have to pay....

Of course, I do depend on interpreters so the interpreters would tell me what's going on even if doctors or nurses may not tell us in dangerous health issue. That's why I need ears so the interpeters would tell us everything. Too bad, doctors or nurses already opened their mouths...
 
mld4ds said:
Hospital provides us ASL interpeters. We do not have to pay....

Of course, I do depend on interpreters so the interpreters would tell me what's going on even if doctors or nurses may not tell us in dangerous health issue. That's why I need ears so the interpeters would tell us everything. Too bad, doctors or nurses already opened their mouths...


Interesting, demand interpreter for childbirth is not known in Europe because it´s not necassary. We have no problem to understand doctors and nurses well but with surgery is a different story.

We have the right to demand an interpreter when there´re surgery preparation / agreement contract with doctors.. but simple childbirth... :eek:
 
My email to the host was not defending the lawsuit. That was a separate issue.

My complaint was that he was ranting about Deaf people and terps in general without any knowledge of the ADA or sign language. He compared hiring terps for Deaf as the same as hiring foreign language terps for every language on the planet for aliens using the hospital. Also, his remark about "skanks" was totally offensive and uncalled for.

I still want to get the transcript so I don't have to depend on my memory to give the exact quotes.

He sent me a reply a few minutes ago. He said he appreciated the info but I should have called him right away while he was on the air. I emailed back to tell him I was driving my car at the time and couldn't call him.
 
Reba said:
Anyway, I wrote a hot email to him as soon as I got home. I am trying to get a transcript of his program. If I do, I will post it.
Whoa about Casey's comment. I'm trying to find that one at his site (audio or transcript) but no luck. I'd love to get Nas to listen to it. I know for fact that she'd give him a piece of her mind via phone or email.
 
Reba, what time did you listen to Casey's 'talk show'? I asked around and someone thinks he/she can find it.
 
When I had my 1st baby, they offered me an interpreter. So I have no complain though. After he came out, then she left. I was fine. I would be fine with or without if I have 2nd baby one day.
 
I don't bring an interpreter..

1st doctor use body languages "PUSH" *BREATH* simple plain communcation.. went well
2nd no communcation... use reilable my hubby who can commcation w/me via doctor or nurse talk.. He is hard of hearing. :D
3rd.. as same my hubby..

Depends critital seriouis health issues baby and have to rights hire an interpreter for c-section no matter what kinds how seriouis goes on...

This Deaf lady is right and have rights to sue... their decision.. which hopsital did MADE ingore Deaf lady's request awful lot..
If I were her shoes.. of course I might to... no matter how's seriouis of my health related the baby... Still counts.
 
Back
Top