Good idea and would be awesome but in most places the deaf population is a great deal smaller than the hearing population so if a theater does captions every day and non captions a few days a week/month- they'd be losing money. Have to wonder if it's more distracting on a big screen like at the movies... Would be an interesting experiment though.
[rant] I agree/understand that the hearing population is bigger, but I feel the ADA was created in the spirit of not letting this become a deciding factor*. I don't think I have ever in my life walked into a theater that was not wheelchair accessible/capable. It's ridiculous that hh/deaf are marginalized so blatantly.
To me not including captioning for hearing population's "convenience" is EXACTLY akin to a teacher saying an interpreter could distract hearing students. Perhaps without the interpreter, a Deaf student would be distracted by their inability to capture information? Perhaps with a lack of captioning, Deaf populations would be inconvenienced by not understanding any audible elements in a movie?
Yeah. Sorry. This issue coming to my attention makes me really angry. Coming from freshly illuminated hearing eyes, the lack of captioning seems completely insane.
I can think of lots of means of bringing awareness to this issue, but almost all these ideas require cooperation from a major theater chain. For instance, one day all theaters could turn off their sound for awareness. But of course they would not.
I read about that man pulling a fire alarm in anger due to watching a caption Avengers showing... How ridiculously idiotic and intolerant can a person be? Crazy.
/anger
Post script: As long as the words are stationed below the major action, I don't see how the big screen would make it more distracting. I recently had a friend living with us who did not want the CC on while we watched things, which we always keep on for total comprehension (neither me nor my SO have below normal hearing). We had become so used to being able to refer to the CC while watching complicated plots (think Breaking Bad) that we kept getting lost during quiet dialogue scenes. It was really frustrating, and we can hear! Like most innovations designed to benefit minority populations (think wheelchair ramps), I think captioning would ultimately benefit the majority population in unexpected ways as well if they were simply open to it** being a fact of life.
*Also, these theaters wouldn't be losing money if it were required across the board, and captioning seems cheaper than a lot of "handicap accessible" features.
**I don't think the majority should be allowed to feel open or not open to the idea, just like ramps. It's an accessibility issue that should be addressed whether the majority feels like it or not.
Omg [/rant]