Children with cochlear implants have quality of life equal to normal hearing peers

Lighthouse77

New Member
Joined
Mar 24, 2009
Messages
4,166
Reaction score
1
Children who have cochlear implants (CI) rank their quality of life (QOL) equal to their normally hearing (NH) peers, indicates new research in the February 2010 issue of Otolaryngology - Head and Neck Surgery.

A cochlear implant is an electronic device that restores partial hearing to the deaf. It is surgically implanted in the inner ear and activated by a device worn outside the ear. Unlike a hearing aid, it does not make sound louder or clearer. Instead, the device bypasses damaged parts of the auditory system and directly stimulates the hearing nerve, allowing deaf or severely hard of hearing individuals to receive sound. The National Institutes of Health estimate that as many as 59,000 people worldwide have received cochlear implants, with roughly half of those in the pediatric population.

Prior research has indicated that deaf children feel less socially accepted, experience more difficulty in making friends, and demonstrate greater adjustment problems than their hearing peers. The subsequent success of the multi-channel CI devices that improve speech perception and language development led researchers to look beyond speech and language performance to questions of psycho-social behaviors and adjustment.

This cross-sectional study of 88 families with CI children from 16 U.S. states used a generic QOL questionnaire. The group was then divided by age of the child when they filled out the questionnaire: an 8-11-year-old group and a 12-16-year-old group. Both parents and children were asked to fill out the QOL questionnaire, with the parents assessing their child. The study group was then compared to a control group of 1,501 NH children in fourth and eighth grades.

Results of the questionnaire revealed that overall QOL did not differ between CI and NH groups. However, examination of individual subscales revealed that 8-11-year-old CI children rate their QOL with family less positively than their NH peers. Younger CI recipients rated overall QOL more positively than the older 12-16-year-old CI group. However, the authors point out that this could be a reflection of standard adolescent behavior. Overall QOL showed a significant inverse association with age at implantation, and a significant positive correlation with duration of CI use in the 12-16-year-old group.

The authors point out that even though prior studies have assessed QOL in CI children, this study adds additional perspective to the literature, as it combines assessments by the actual CI recipients and parents, and it maps the results in context with NH children. In addition to findings about how CI children rank their QOL, the research reveals that parents proved to be reliable reporters for their children in areas where they could observe and participate.

The authors write, "For profoundly deaf children who regularly use a cochlear implant, feelings about life overall are no better or worse than their hearing peers. These findings indicate that cochlear implantation has a positive effect on certain psycho-social domains."


Provided by American Academy of Otolaryngology -- Head and Neck Surgery


Children with cochlear implants have quality of life equal to normal hearing peers
 
This cross-sectional study of 88 families with CI children from 16 U.S. states
A rather small population for a study like this.
It's good that some kids are doing OK socially....but then again it says things may change from when kids are little to adolesence....which seems to be very very common.
 
you noticed that their quality of Life with family is not all that good compare to hearing children. That should tell you trouble is brewing there. I do wonder if these kids know and use ASL and what type of school they go to and what type of friends they have (hearing friends or CI/deaf friends? ). Because I believe bi-bi is the key to well-adjusted life.
 
Geez..another study indirectly implying that deaf children without CIs are abnormal. Wonderful!
 
This is where I really disagree with studies because it is only for a short period of time; verification isn't complete with statistics and data.
 
Geez..another study indirectly implying that deaf children without CIs are abnormal. Wonderful!

Haven't you asked on many threads if kids with CI's are social trouble? here is a study that directly asked those questions. It says that in the past deaf kids have scored themselves much lower on quality of life, but that kids with CI's don't. That is a big deal.
 
it's too early to tell, just wait for 10 more years to go then we all will know for sure.
 
Haven't you asked on many threads if kids with CI's are social trouble? here is a study that directly asked those questions. It says that in the past deaf kids have scored themselves much lower on quality of life, but that kids with CI's don't. That is a big deal.

Those deaf probably did not know ASL and attended mainstream school. Or have discrimination issues (even family problem because the family don't take the time to learn ASL).

How do we know these kids know ASL or not? I think majority of the CI users here know ASL.
 
Those deaf probably did not know ASL and attended mainstream school.

How do we know these kids know ASL or not? I think majority of the CI users here know ASL.

We don't know if they use ASL, but I believe stats show that most kids with CI's don't know ASL.

We were involved in a similar study (obviously for younger kids) and they were very through and asked what kind of school she attended and what languages she used and at what age she was dx'ed and implanted.
 
Hmm, I wonder how many CI implantees became a homeowner at the age of 24. I'll wager not a lot of them out there. Heck, a lot of hearing adults still live with their parents in their 20s and 30s.
 
If these stupid idiots would see everyone at the AD meet on Sat night, for sure they wouldnt dare to describe our lives as of lower quality than hearing people. :roll: This whole thing is just fucking stupid.
 
If these stupid idiots would see everyone at the AD meet on Sat night, for sure they wouldnt dare to describe our lives as of lower quality than hearing people. :roll: This whole thing is just fucking stupid.

They don't say that they believe the children's lives are "lower quality" than hearing people, the kids do! How do you blame the people who did the study?? They simply send out questionaires about how they feel they fit in, how stressfull they find school, if they have trouble communication with their friends, etc. It isn't a judgement. The deaf kids (until now) have been rating *themselves* lower in happiness than hearing kids do.
 
They don't say that they believe the children's lives are "lower quality" than hearing people, the kids do! How do you blame the people who did the study?? They simply send out questionaires about how they feel they fit in, how stressfull they find school, if they have trouble communication with their friends, etc. It isn't a judgement. The deaf kids (until now) have been rating *themselves* lower in happiness than hearing kids do.

You really have no idea, do you? How demeaning it is to even compare in the first place. Just stupidity.
 
They don't say that they believe the children's lives are "lower quality" than hearing people, the kids do! How do you blame the people who did the study?? They simply send out questionaires about how they feel they fit in, how stressfull they find school, if they have trouble communication with their friends, etc. It isn't a judgement. The deaf kids (until now) have been rating *themselves* lower in happiness than hearing kids do.

There it is.... the study is not infallible because the children cannot believe they are living better than the others if they have never experienced a lower quality of life.
 
You really have no idea, do you? How demeaning it is to even compare in the first place. Just stupidity.

So many people have said in previous threads that it needs studied!

How can you claim that mainstreamed kids are less socially adept, and struggle if no one studies it!?

So many people claim that mainstreamed or oral only kids have social or adjustment problems, the only way to find out if it is true is to do the research. Have you seen the number of blogs discussing just this issue? Part of Audism Free Anerica's demands from AG BEll was studies like this!
 
They probably feel more socially accepted because hearing people are more acceptable toward them because they have CI and don't act like a deaf person. Otherwise, hearing would just exclude them. yep, kinda sad that we have to do everything their way.


Next study: The tale of two cities: how to get deaf people fit in the hearing world.
 
They probably feel more socially accepted because hearing people are more acceptable toward them because they have CI and don't act like a deaf person. Otherwise, hearing would just exclude them. yep, kinda sad that we have to do everything their way.


Next study: The tale of two cities: how to get deaf people fit in the hearing world.

It could be..just too many factors. However, the solution is ASL and being around other deaf peers which makes me pissed off.
 


Write your reply...
Back
Top