Officers Beat and Stun Deaf Man After He Tries to Communicate Through Sign Language

rockin'robin

Well-Known Member
Joined
Apr 22, 2007
Messages
24,431
Reaction score
549
While investigating a burglary, four police officers beat a deaf man until he became unconscious.




The Hawthorne Police Department (HPD) hit Jonathan Meister with a stunt gun, shocked him with a taser and beat him until he ended up in the hospital claiming that they mistook the deaf man’s efforts to communicate as aggressive hand signals.

The Greater Los Angeles Agency on Deafness is filing a lawsuit on behalf of Meister, who was charged with assault as a result of the incident.

According to the lawsuit, Meister was retrieving boxes he had left at a friend’s house, with his friend’s consent, when the four officers, notified by a neighbor to a possible burglary, arrived.

“They ended up grabbing his arms and turning him around, and if you do that to a deaf person, it’s like gagging them,” his lawyer John Burton told the Daily News on Tuesday. “It would be like if I put my hand over your mouth and you’re trying to tell me something.”

Meister also reflexively pulled his arms away and jumped over a small fence to create space so he could better communicate, but officers took that as an act of aggression as well.

Meister is suing the police for violating his civil rights under the American with Disabilities Act. “This incident occurred,” the lawsuit states, “in substantial part because the HPD does not provide its officers the training and resources to serve people who are deaf or hard of hearing.”

The lawsuit also states that the Hawthorne Police Department failed, “to provide effective communication to deaf and hard of hearing individuals, including himself, who come into contact and interact with the HPD, thereby discriminating against them.”

The HPD released a statement to NBC regarding the incident.

Check out the video above for more on the story.

http://firsttoknow.com/innocent-deaf-man-gets-beat-deaf/?utm_source=facebookpage
 
Where is CP? Please send him to handle this case.
 
Where is CP? Please send him to handle this case.
What? Why me? Didn't you read that there's a deaf organization called GLAD which currently handles this case? So I am not needed. LOL

BTW, police has no excuse to grab him like that. For example, if I am an educated cop, I would yell at him first to halt and if he doesn't respond, that means he's deaf. They jumped to conclusions because they are uneducated. SMH Therefore, HPD must pay for failing to educate cops.
 
What? Why me? Didn't you read that there's a deaf organization called GLAD which currently handles this case? So I am not needed. LOL

BTW, police has no excuse to grab him like that. For example, if I am an educated cop, I would yell at him first to halt and if he doesn't respond, that means he's deaf. They jumped to conclusions because they are uneducated. SMH Therefore, HPD must pay for failing to educate cops.

Oh wow, you are apathy.

You told me that you care about deaf people so quit being apathy and get your butt off to take care of deaf people - be advocacy.
 
Read a quote on this story where 1 hearing man said...."The deaf want equal rights...so he got it this time"...needless to say, I blasted him for it.
 
Hopw he recovers...and gets rich from rhe law suit..
Tipical cops...
 
Oh wow, you are apathy.

You told me that you care about deaf people so quit being apathy and get your butt off to take care of deaf people - be advocacy.
Wow, what's really wrong with you? Grow up, kiddo! Can you read?
 
What? Why me? Didn't you read that there's a deaf organization called GLAD which currently handles this case? So I am not needed. LOL

BTW, police has no excuse to grab him like that. For example, if I am an educated cop, I would yell at him first to halt and if he doesn't respond, that means he's deaf. They jumped to conclusions because they are uneducated. SMH Therefore, HPD must pay for failing to educate cops.

Did you forget there are those that can hear and don't want to stop?

Because of those people, police can't assume each one is deaf.
 
Did you forget there are those that can hear and don't want to stop?

Because of those people, police can't assume each one is deaf.
What are you saying? Is that why he got beaten up since the police thought he pretended to be deaf?

It doesn't matter now because HDP will be required to pay for their mistakes that should not be made by educated cops. Moving on...
 
What are you saying? Is that why he got beaten up since the police thought he pretended to be deaf?

It doesn't matter now because HDP will be required to pay for their mistakes that should not be made by educated cops. Moving on...

ugh!! There is no point in discussing with you since you obviously do not have common sense.
 
How would you assume the person is deaf? If the person doesn't respond doesn't mean he/she is deaf, they will ignore the cop and try to get away. That's how typical crooks is.

There is crooks/criminals that can fool the police officers to get away, doesn't matter if the police officer is educated or not. They face danger everyday on the streets protecting the law and law abiding citizens.

BTW, police has no excuse to grab him like that. For example, if I am an educated cop, I would yell at him first to halt and if he doesn't respond, that means he's deaf. They jumped to conclusions because they are uneducated. SMH Therefore, HPD must pay for failing to educate cops.
 
Last edited:
Oh my god, CP shouldn't mess with Texans.

He's New Jerseyan-Californian.
 
BTW, police has no excuse to grab him like that. For example, if I am an educated cop, I would yell at him first to halt and if he doesn't respond, that means he's deaf. They jumped to conclusions because they are uneducated. SMH Therefore, HPD must pay for failing to educate cops.

To add to what others have said... the person being yelled at could be someone who doesn't necessarily speak/understand English (there are American citizens who do not speak English as a first language). Or perhaps the individual is autistic (yes it's possible)- with that they'd be in a world of bigger trouble too.

I hope no Police force ever hires you... assuming a person is deaf just because he didn't respond is just as bad as assuming everyone the police comes in contact isn't deaf.
 
Whatever you say, it's no excuse. Look what happened to him. It's NOT the first time. Deaf people get hurt by uneducated cops. For example, if I am a hearing cop and I am a son of the deaf parents, I would know what to do. The problem is that cops who are not a son/daughter of the deaf parents have no education about deaf culture. They are everywhere and they can hurt/kill you because you can't hear them.

I have posted the YT video regarding education for cops about deaf culture a while ago. I think it was uploaded by NAD.

"Cops beating you up and then finding out that you are deaf", "Oh well, you didn't hear me so you deserve it", and so on... Really?

Calvin, DeafDucky, Foxrac and Secretblend, your posts are the dumbest ones I have heard in the deaf world. SAD!
 
Years ago. my deaf friend came home to find the Police had surrounded his home where his parents lived...he was shocked...and thought his Parents were hurt or something...He parked his car on the street and started running towards his house...not knowing the Police were yelling to "Stop"!...He was tackled by a Police Officer before he could get to the front door....Luckily, he was not shot....

To find an escapee from prison had broken into his parents home and held them hostage....It all worked out well tho,...SWAT and the Police finally convinced the escapee to surrender.....

We Deafies are in danger of getting shot moreso than hearing I believe....
 
Whatever you say, it's no excuse. Look what happened to him. It's NOT the first time. Deaf people get hurt by uneducated cops. For example, if I am a hearing cop and I am a son of the deaf parents, I would know what to do. The problem is that cops who are not a son/daughter of the deaf parents have no education about deaf culture. They are everywhere and they can hurt/kill you because you can't hear them.

I have posted the YT video regarding education for cops about deaf culture a while ago. I think it was uploaded by NAD.

"Cops beating you up and then finding out that you are deaf", "Oh well, you didn't hear me so you deserve it", and so on... Really?

Calvin, DeafDucky, Foxrac and Secretblend, your posts are the dumbest ones I have heard in the deaf world. SAD!

LOL!!! I feel good. :lol:
 
Years ago. my deaf friend came home to find the Police had surrounded his home where his parents lived...he was shocked...and thought his Parents were hurt or something...He parked his car on the street and started running towards his house...not knowing the Police were yelling to "Stop"!...He was tackled by a Police Officer before he could get to the front door....Luckily, he was not shot....

To find an escapee from prison had broken into his parents home and held them hostage....It all worked out well tho,...SWAT and the Police finally convinced the escapee to surrender.....

We Deafies are in danger of getting shot moreso than hearing I believe....

I agree. I have same experience about Cops not think about deaf existence in everywhere before they looked at my Hearing Aids. I didn't tell them that i am deaf first place with my voice and did not gesture with my hands to let them know that i am deaf. I was walking with my deaf friend to home late night. We took shortcut and Cop in his car saw us walking thru cemetery. He pulled up near us and he talked to us. I can barely hear him clearly. I have to come close to him to hear him talking us. He defensively get out his police car quickly. AND He asked us "Why didn't Yall answer my 3rd question." i was about to tell him but he examined me quickly to see if i have on hearing aids or something. He said "Oh, I sorry. You all are deaf?" I was 6'1, my friend was short and White cop was 6'3 or '4 taller than me . he was big guy. We were about get our butts kick. if i don't have on my hearing aids, i believe most cop might not take time to think i am deaf. They will think i am hearing or mischief. I not saying Hearing Aids save our lives. It is possible we Deafies are not SAFE. We need to think about cop are in danger too. Police do have negative opinion about the public. They HAVE time to think but they DON'T TAKE time to think.
 
Calvin, DeafDucky, Foxrac and Secretblend, your posts are the dumbest ones I have heard in the deaf world. SAD!

At least I'm in good company!



 
Back
Top