Many people don't want advice, they want sympathy or feedback to rest their case, if you've ventured outside of AD.
Myself for one, I don't go public with my relationship problems if there were any.
As for the real purpose parody aside, like I mentioned earlier, ExR was only going to see "you're wrong" and not why the boyfriend was angry. So, his thread backfired. This was the point in my version, so he could see the other side instead of completely missing the issue.
I may have been too crude with my method to answering his problem in using reverse psychology. If this is the case that it offends people, I apologize.