No, because if he didn't have the operation, I have already made the decision for him. He could always take it off later, and hearing aids will not help a profound child like mine. And why surgery? Because it's the only way that the implant will work. I have already discussed with my son when the totally implantable implants become available, would he want it? His answer- NO, I like to hear and be deaf too. I have peace when I want it and I can hear when I want to . I have the best of both worlds. To me, that's a good enough answer,.