Broken record........
shel90 - That is great if you are having success with ASL and literacy. Why do you insist on making the comparison.
There are so many variables to successful deaf education. I cue for English and if you were to "step outside the box", then perhaps you aquire the understanding and experience of learning Cued Speech. To insist that deaf/hoh children from hearing families learn English is imo oppression of deaf/hoh children from hearing families.
Why make aquiring/learning English such an arduous task?