Efforts to evaluate different methods

jillio

New Member
Joined
Jun 14, 2006
Messages
60,232
Reaction score
19
Seventy four children from seven pre-school progrmas throughout the U.S. were involved in the study. For the test period, when children had a mean age of approximately 5 years, a receptive communications test was administered with the following results:

Speech alone used to present message: 34% of content was understood.

Speech plus speechreading: 56% of content understood.

Speech, speech reading, and figerspelling: 61% of content understood

Speech, speechreading and signs: 71% of content understood.

Children with the highest scores in speech reception plus speechreading were from programs using manual and oral communication from the time the children started their education, suggesting that, instead of inhibiting the reception of spoken language, early manual communication facilitates it.

Choice of communication mode is one of the important decisions in which the educational system has a profound effect on the life of a deaf child.



The above was taken from Deafness and Child Dvelopment, Kathryn Meadows.

As we have discussed this is several other threads, and I keep getting asked for something to support my claims, I thought I'd offer this.
 
Wow..only 34% of the content was understood in the oral only approach? Time to say bye bye to the oral-only approach!

I would rather get 71% of the content than 34%.

To those who support the oral only philosophy, is 34 to 50% acceptable?
 
Wow..only 34% of the content was understood in the oral only approach? Time to say bye bye to the oral-only approach!

I would rather get 71% of the content than 34%.

To those who support the oral only philosophy, is 34 to 50% acceptable?

Exactly! And that 71% applied to 5 year old kids. It would increase as vocab and development increases.
And those who support the oral only approach probably won't even bother to read this. All they seem to be concerned with is CI.
 
Exactly! And that 71% applied to 5 year old kids. It would increase as vocab and development increases.
And those who support the oral only approach probably won't even bother to read this. All they seem to be concerned with is CI.

Hey off the point...my son is language delayed in both sign language and spoken language. He is at the 9 month old level and got accepted in the special ed program for speech/ language development.

So strange cuz he is exposed to both but yet, his receptive and expressive skills are delayed. HmMMM. He has not said one word in spoken language yet and he is almost 2 but has been using signs. The specialists said that he should have over 50 signs by now and he only signs about 10 to 15 words. I was impressed that the specialists who dont specialize in deaf ed took the time to go over research on language development of signers. It really pleased me.

His hearing tests are still inconclusive. Will go again when he is 2 in October.

Also, he is starting to show signs of OCD-like behaviors.

His first session with the speech therapist is on Wed. Will be interesting to see how it is done. HMMMM...
 
Hey off the point...my son is language delayed in both sign language and spoken language. He is at the 9 month old level and got accepted in the special ed program for speech/ language development.

So strange cuz he is exposed to both but yet, his receptive and expressive skills are delayed. HmMMM. He has not said one word in spoken language yet and he is almost 2 but has been using signs. The specialists said that he should have over 50 signs by now and he only signs about 10 to 15 words. I was impressed that the specialists who dont specialize in deaf ed took the time to go over research on language development of signers. It really pleased me.

His hearing tests are still inconclusive. Will go again when he is 2 in October.

Also, he is starting to show signs of OCD-like behaviors.

His first session with the speech therapist is on Wed. Will be interesting to see how it is done. HMMMM...

I'm sure you learned this in grad school, but a lot of kids with mild losses will exhibit some OCD tendencies. There moss is so mild that it really isn't picked up on, but about the age of 2, when they start to develop that independent identity, they realize that there are some things going on inthier world that they can't control and the behaviors are their way of taking back control of their worlds.

I would't worry too much. Boys are often much slower than girls in their langauge development.
As long as he is able to make his needs known, he may not see the need to work too hard at it right now. I don't mean to be mean or try to make a diagnosis over this post, but there is also a chance of mild autism--those behaviors also go along with that. But I'm sure you already considered that, given your background and knowlege. Keep me informed. I care!
 
I'm sure you learned this in grad school, but a lot of kids with mild losses will exhibit some OCD tendencies. There moss is so mild that it really isn't picked up on, but about the age of 2, when they start to develop that independent identity, they realize that there are some things going on inthier world that they can't control and the behaviors are their way of taking back control of their worlds.

I would't worry too much. Boys are often much slower than girls in their langauge development.
As long as he is able to make his needs known, he may not see the need to work too hard at it right now. I don't mean to be mean or try to make a diagnosis over this post, but there is also a chance of mild autism--those behaviors also go along with that. But I'm sure you already considered that, given your background and knowlege. Keep me informed. I care!

Yea, I cant help comparing him to my daughter but my daughter wasnt exposed to sign language when she was his age because I didnt know it. I have to stop doing that.

He has fits if all the doors are not closed..even the cabinet doors must be closed or he freaks out. He must have vitamins in his milk...he is only supposed to get that at nights but he is demanding it in his milk all the time and he would resort to head banging if he doesnt get vitamins in his milk. Sometimes he would bang his head for no reason and I have to stop him. Just some funny things I am noticing and yea, with my experience working with children of all kinds of special needs...it is either I am paranoid or able to identify them so early.

He is very social and loves people so maybe I am just making a big deal out of it. LOL! However, the specialist idenified his delays so I was right on that one. I expressed his OCD-like behaviors and they will keep an eye out for them. They said that I could be right because with the rise in autism, u never know and it is always better to idenitify it earlier rather than later.

The lady who will work with him knows sign language so she will use both with him. So nice even though he has not been officially diagnosed with hearing losses. :)

I just want the program to meet his needs...that comes first.
 
Yea, I cant help comparing him to my daughter but my daughter wasnt exposed to sign language when she was his age because I didnt know it. I have to stop doing that.

He has fits if all the doors are not closed..even the cabinet doors must be closed or he freaks out. He must have vitamins in his milk...he is only supposed to get that at nights but he is demanding it in his milk all the time and he would resort to head banging if he doesnt get vitamins in his milk. Sometimes he would bang his head for no reason and I have to stop him. Just some funny things I am noticing and yea, with my experience working with children of all kinds of special needs...it is either I am paranoid or able to identify them so early.

He is very social and loves people so maybe I am just making a big deal out of it. LOL! However, the specialist idenified his delays so I was right on that one. I expressed his OCD-like behaviors and they will keep an eye out for them. They said that I could be right because with the rise in autism, u never know and it is always better to idenitify it earlier rather than later.

The lady who will work with him knows sign language so she will use both with him. So nice even though he has not been officially diagnosed with hearing losses. :)

I just want the program to meet his needs...that comes first.

If he is that outgoing, chances are it isn't autism. Sounds more like a control issue with him. My son was like that. Had to use a certain cup at breakfast, and a different one at lunch, etc. It's great that they are goingto sue sign and speech to work with him, since that is what he knows and is used to. And absolutley, his needs being met is first priority.
 
If he is that outgoing, chances are it isn't autism. Sounds more like a control issue with him. My son was like that. Had to use a certain cup at breakfast, and a different one at lunch, etc. It's great that they are goingto sue sign and speech to work with him, since that is what he knows and is used to. And absolutley, his needs being met is first priority.

Ugh..he is gonna be a control freak? He better not control women when he grows up or his ass will be kicked! :giggle:
 
I was raised with speech, speechreading, and signing.
 
Ugh..he is gonna be a control freak? He better not control women when he grows up or his ass will be kicked! :giggle:

Probably not.:D Just exerting his control now when it is developmentally appropriate for him to do so! It's something new to him, and he's experiemtning with it.

Good for you, Mom! Teach him to respect women!
 
If he is that outgoing, chances are it isn't autism. Sounds more like a control issue with him.
Yes indeedy..............Although he might have a language based learning disabilty. I know that some LDs can manifest early as language delays. It's really hard to tell early on. Maybe it's just symptoms of mild losses.
Oh, and jillo do you have any research about verbal IQ? Verbal IQ corrallates with mastery of a language. If oral only worked, then oral dhh kids would have higher verbal IQs then TC or bi-bi kids.
 
Yes indeedy..............Although he might have a language based learning disabilty. I know that some LDs can manifest early as language delays. It's really hard to tell early on. Maybe it's just symptoms of mild losses.
Oh, and jillo do you have any research about verbal IQ? Verbal IQ corrallates with mastery of a language. If oral only worked, then oral dhh kids would have higher verbal IQs then TC or bi-bi kids.

Yes, I've got some research somewhere. I'll look for it!
 
Not to worry you or anything but my son is autistic and he is extremely outgoing. He used to be a head banger but he's grown out of that thankfully. I just wanted to let everyone know that while the classic "symptoms" of autism state the kids are loners in their own worlds it does not mean that they can't be very social and very affectionate.
 
Not to worry you or anything but my son is autistic and he is extremely outgoing. He used to be a head banger but he's grown out of that thankfully. I just wanted to let everyone know that while the classic "symptoms" of autism state the kids are loners in their own worlds it does not mean that they can't be very social and very affectionate.


Thanks for sharing! I appreciate that very much..will keep an eye on him. How old was your son when he was diagnosed with autisim?
 
Not to worry you or anything but my son is autistic and he is extremely outgoing. He used to be a head banger but he's grown out of that thankfully. I just wanted to let everyone know that while the classic "symptoms" of autism state the kids are loners in their own worlds it does not mean that they can't be very social and very affectionate.

Hi were you talking about higher functioning of autism like Asperger's Syndrome like one for example or there is more? I saw a News program on TV about a high school student that has Asperger's Syndrome and he appear to be quite normal as compared to other students. I noticed that many of my friends had strange behaviors when they were young and they outgrown them in many cases.
 
Not to worry you or anything but my son is autistic and he is extremely outgoing. He used to be a head banger but he's grown out of that thankfully. I just wanted to let everyone know that while the classic "symptoms" of autism state the kids are loners in their own worlds it does not mean that they can't be very social and very affectionate.

Agreed, but as john57 stated these are the milder forms, and even though they can be quite affectionate and outgoing, they are still usually more reserved with strangers and in unfamiliar situations, and have a great deal of difficulty experiencing empathy.
 
PROGRAMS

THE RACE AGAINST TIME FOR LITERACY

Most people have acquired up to 85% of their adult capacity for language by the time they are five years old. This basis in language is the fundamental key to reading readiness. If a child is prevented from developing this language awareness at the appropriate age because of a hearing loss or other cause, their potential for attaining adult literacy levels may be permanently hampered. Furthermore, for many children, the hearing loss may not be diagnosed until they are over a year old, with a whole critical year of language acquisition already lost to them. AEHI’s programs use Cued Speech as a tool with demonstrated effectiveness for making the sounds and structure of language visually accessible for people who are hearing impaired.


COMMUNICATION

Ninety-five percent of children who are deaf or hard of hearing are born to hearing parents. If the parents must learn a whole new language, Sign Language, in order to communicate with their baby, the child will only acquire language as quickly as the parents are able to learn the vocabulary of this new language. This process further slows the child’s acquisition of language skills. Cued Speech is a visual form of English, not a different language. It can be learned in under twenty hours of instruction. Parents are instantly able to communicate every word they can say, every thought they can conceive, in a way that is visually accessible to their child.

WHAT IS CUED SPEECH?

Cued Speech is a communication system that combines hand cues with the natural mouth movements of speech in a way that allows a deaf person to have complete visual access to spoken language, phoneme by phoneme, in much the same way as a hearing person has auditory access. In English, there are eight Cued Speech handshapes which, seen together with the natural mouth movements of speech, represent the 25 different consonant sounds of English. There are four different locations around the mouth which, together with the natural mouth movements of speech, represent the 15 different vowels and diphthongs used in English. Basically, one “cues” consonant/vowel pairs or lone consonants or vowels by placing the appropriate handshapes in the appropriate vowel locations in synchronization with all of the natural mouth movements of spoken English (with OR without use of the “speaker’s” voice).

With Cued Speech, the deaf person can “see” exactly what is being said with close to 100% accuracy. This is in sharp contrast to what a deaf person can accurately receive via speechreading alone. The best speechreaders achieve about 35-40% -- and that’s if they already know English. Since so many sounds look alike or are invisible on the mouth, deaf children cannot possibly learn the English language through speechreading alone. With Cued Speech, consonant sounds that look alike on the mouth will be Cued with different handshapes – and look-alike vowel sounds will be Cued in different locations. It effectively makes the sounds of the spoken word visible. Cued Speech is compatible with oral/aural, total communication and bilingual philosophies, enhancing communication and instruction in each mode.


CUED SPEECH AND LITERACY

Delayed acquisition of the concepts of language caused by hearing loss often hampers the process of learning to read. As a result, the average deaf adult who is the product of traditional deaf education reads at or below a fifth grade level. The use of Cued Speech as a teaching tool facilitates the achievement of an individual’s full potential for literacy.



ARTICLES ON CUED SPEECH



Recent articles on Cued Speech are available in Odyssey Fall 2003 published by the Laurent Clerc National Deaf Education Center at Gallaudet University.

To view these articles you must have Adobe Acrobat Reader installed on your computer.

RESEARCH AND THEORY SUPPORT CUED SPEECH (PDF - 944 kb)
By Carol LaSasso & Kelly Lamar Crain

PHONEMIC AWARENESS THROUGH IMMERSION IN CUED AMERICAN ENGLISH (PDF - 1.12kb)
By Kitri Larson Kyllo

CUED SPEECH & AMERICAN SIGN LANGUAGE
HAND IN HAND (PDF - 499 kb)
By Harry Wood

COMMUNICATING VIA CUED SPEECH (PDF - 631 kb)
By Ami Tsuji-Jones



CUED SPEECH: A PROMISING PRACTICE IN DEAF EDUCATION

The Failure of Deaf Education Today

Literacy denied:
Nationally the average reading level of a deaf person who has completed all years of schooling is at or below a fifth grade level.

“Full Educational Opportunity” denied:
The majority of these children are being denied access to the general curriculum which is a violation of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). It is also a violation of the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) to deny hearing-impaired children the opportunity to derive the same benefit from their education as non-hearing-impaired children.

Most of these children are trapped in Special Education for their entire academic careers.

Why are today’s practices failing?
Today’s programs fail because they use communication modes and teaching methods which do not provide hearing-impaired children with the English language competence and phonemic awareness necessary for achieving literacy and academic excellence.

Some public school programs use American Sign Language (ASL) which is a visual / gestural language which has its own grammar and syntax which are distinct from those of English. It has no written equivalent. These programs are called bilingual-bicultural, wherein all instruction is done in ASL, and English is taught as a second language through written format.

For over thirty years, most public school programs have been using a method of education called “Total Communication.” Total Communication is an umbrella term which may encompass a variety of communication modes and teaching methods. Most Total Communication programs use simultaneous speech and signs presented in English word order in an attempt to systematically represent English for the child with a hearing impairment.

Neither of the above approaches succeeds because sign language, whether in English word order or not, is a conceptual language which does not impart the vocabulary, syntax, phonetics, or idiom of English -- all of which are critical to literacy and academic success.

Another educational option is the “oral/aural” approach, which teaches speech and English language through technology-aided hearing supplemented by speech reading. For children who cannot hear all of the sounds of spoken English, relying on speech reading as the only supplement is insufficient because too many sounds are indistinguishable on the mouth.

How to Turn Failure into Success

Is there a successful solution?
Yes: Cued Speech. Children who use Cued Speech generally attain language and reading levels equal to their hearing peers!

What is Cued Speech?

Cued Speech is a communication system which makes spoken English completely visually accessible to a child who is hearing impaired. The Cued Speech system uses eight hand shapes representing consonant sounds and four locations near the mouth representing vowel sounds. Consonants are cued in the appropriate vowel locations, syllable by syllable in synchronization with the mouth movements of speech (with or without voice). Cues supplement what is seen on the mouth in such a way as to make spoken language clear through vision alone.

Many studies confirm that deaf children do not achieve age-appropriate English language and reading levels. Cued Speech kids do.

Cued Speech Center for the Deaf in Mt. Prospect Illinois
 
If the diagnosis come in after 1 year of age, then the CS would not be used until after the daignosis has come in. How does this prevent language deprivation prior to that time?

"Making the sound of language available".......that is assuming that the only language is an oral language. Wrong! "Hearing impaired"....yet another insulting term that the hearing world has dreamed up to promote the medicalized view of deafness. It is only by keepingthe definition of deafness as impairment and something to be fixed that the oralist philosophy has any ground to stand on. Keep them disabled, at all costs, so we can promeote new ways to fix them.

Learning sign language....please read the studies that indicate that even when presented with a less than perfect model of sign language, the deaf child will surpass the models due to innate cognitive mechanisms that allow one to intuit the features of a language. And since when does a 2 year old child have the same vocablulary as an adult? They are not capable of learning adult concepts, therefore, the parent can increase their skills as the needs of the child for more sophisticated linguistic concepts increases. If a child were able to communicate on the same linguistic level as an adult, we wouldn't hear so many hearing parents talking to hearing children in phrases such as "See doggie?"

And yes, delayed concept acquisition does contribute to decreased literacy. And CS does nothing to overcome this. We have already discussed this inthe other thread you posted regarding CS. Making a morpheme visable does absolutly nothing to transmit conceptual information.


2003 is not recent. There has been a renewed effert to bring CS back into the foreforont because of the new generation of CI students who are now experiencing the same problems that HA students had inthe past. CS did not solve those problems, and they will not solve these because they have the same bais for the problem. Why do you insit on repeating history? That is why literacy rates are low. And the 5th grade reading level is outdated. Those are statistics from the 1980's. CS is not going to solve the problem of full access,any more than CI has solved the problem of full access.

I want to see the studies that prove that CS kids attain achievement levels equal to their hearing peers. If this were a proven fact, it is something that would be used educationally all over. Instead, it is just another invention of the oralist camp. They finallyhad to admit that visual cues are necessary, but instead of relying on the method that has achieved success int he past, they say--Oh, no! Stay in that limiting oral mind set, just add this little trick to make it look like the visual is not so necessary. PUHLEEZE!
 
Austin was diagnosed at 3 years old and is high functioning but not Aspergers. He is ok with most strangers if in a group but will not go anywhere with a stranger alone. He used to be terrible with anyone new but school has helped him. He wasn't very verbal when we first found out. After several years of intense speech therapy he now won't be quiet. He still has some trouble telling you what he needs/wants and has some articulation problems. He still uses some very basic signs to let me know what he needs when he is over stimulated.

Autism is a spectrum disorder. There are many different labels to discribe what each category typically behave like. Aspergers is very high functioning. Hyperlexics have a tendency to teach themselves to read and are good with numbers at any early age. My son's official diagnosis is PDD-NOS (pervasive developmental disorder-not otherwise specifies) which falls under the spectrum.

If you have any questions you can contact me.
 
Back
Top